Barnaby's is great no matter what you order and consistent. You can count on the quality to be the same each time you dine here, in or out. Would highly recommend and get a pizza.
D
Devon B
Local Expert • 93 contributions
Liked
• 30/08/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was delivered neatly packaged. We received the whole order. The portions were huge for the price. Neither of us could finish our dinners. The Italian combo meal my husband ordered;said he would order again. But the fries were only par cooked. They were very solid and mealy on the inside. The cheese bread hit the spot.
B
Bridget G
Emerging Expert • 32 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/05/23
• DoorDash order
Usually good but there was barely any sausage, barely any toppings at all. It was like getting a cheese pizza. I ordered double sausage, mushroom and green pepper. I paid for double sausage and there wasn't even the amount without the double. And it was doughy. I had to bake it before eating. Very disappointed.
D
Danny W
Local Expert • 33 contributions
Didn't like
• 25/10/25
• DoorDash order
Tossed Salad (Full) wasn't as it was ordered. It was ordered with lots of our usual toppings and vinaigrette. And we thought some of the tomatoes were pineapple because of the color. They gave us ranch dressing and only cucumber and tomato.
Breaded Cauliflower (8 Oz) missing. And our Special Pizza #2 (Large) was dry as if they forgot to put pizza sauce on it.
I love Barnaby's, but our food usually comes from the one downtown South Bend and it's perfect every time. Unsure about this one because this was abysmal. I'll have to check which location doordash is trying to use in the future.
We spent nearly $70 for a terrible meal.
J
Jasmine L
5 contributions
Loved
• 30/05/26
• DoorDash order
Wings and pizza was very good, it's definitely my go to place when the family have last minute gatherings, it was decently portioned and everyone was score to get full, also came fresh
