Mr. Scrib's Pizza
4.6(200+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
4.6(200+)•
Pizzeria
Mr. Scribs Pizza, the better pizza baker, has been around for over 45 years and has been serving the public a uniquely secretly blended recipe of total mouth-watering goodness. In addition to our incr…
Full Menu
3:00 pm–10:55 pmFeatured Items
US$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Deluxe (16-Inch (Large))
US$26.55
•88% (17)
#1 most liked
Meat Lovers (16-Inch (Large))
US$27.00
•80% (10)
#3 most liked
1 Topping (16-Inch (Large))
US$22.75
Deluxe (14-Inch (Medium))
US$22.50
Deluxe (12-Inch (Regular))
US$18.80
•85% (7)
3 Topping (16-Inch (Large))
US$26.55
Reviews200+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
Heidi P
Local Expert • 183 contributionsLiked
• 13/09/26I've been eating Mr. Scrib's pizza for many... MANY... years (more than I care to say 😉). I'm pretty sure the one on Laketon was the first pizza place in town, but I'm confident it's older than any other currently around. It's definitely the first pizza I remember ever having.
As is true with all restaurants,they aren't always at their best, but those times are few and far between. Thankfully, last night was NOT one of those nights. It's safe to say it was AT LEAST in the top 10 (if not the top 5) BEST Scrib's pizzas I've had over the... ummm... SEVERAL decades I've been eating their pizza. It was hot and DELICIOUS!
My husband wasn't as lucky as those of us who grew up eating Scrib's pizza. He's originalky from OK, but he's been living in Muskegon for 22+ years. He's always told me that my homemade pizza is his all-time favorite pizza (he's such a sweet-talker 😉🥰😅), but it didn't take him long to decide that Scrib's is his favorite restaurant-made pizza.
Heidi P
Local Expert • 183 contributionsDidn't like
• 1/02/26NOTE: This pertains to tonight's pizza ONLY. Everyone has a bad time of it now and then. This was one of those times.
To say our pizza was overcooked would be generous. A great share of it was burned, some to the point that it was inedible and had to be thrown out.
The small portion that wasn't burned wasn't up to Scrib's usual standards, either. It didn't taste bad, really, but the toppings were very uneven, with several spots having little or no toppings at all (not full pieces, mind you, but many full 'bites').
Heidi P
Local Expert • 183 contributionsLoved
• 20/12/25Our pizzas were a bit overbaked again, which is difficult to manage when one wears dentures. My husband's was more overdone than mine, and after a while he had to give up I would've gladly given up my leftovers for tomorrow (which is one of the reasons we each get our own) and shared my pizza with him, but green olives are like kryptonite to him. LOL!
All that being said, that delicious Mr. Scrib's flavor still shone through! Everybody is entitled to a bad day now and then, and it will take a lot more than that for our loyalties to change. 😊 They are still our #1, as they have been for decades.
Lyza T
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 21/04/26The pizza that we received for dinner was not cooked thoroughly and our extra topping looked like it was placed on after the fact like it was forgotten about I have been ordering Mr. Scribs pizza for the last 40 years and this is by far the worst pizza I've ever had from them. it really was an insult to the usually absolutely delicious one of a kind pizza. Our family has come to know and love
Heidi P
Local Expert • 183 contributionsLoved
• 22/11/25Mr. Scrib's is the 1st pizza I remember EVER having. I'm 60, and I think it was the ONLY pizza place in town then. I can't say it's my favorite pizza ever, but it's sure in my top 5. it brings back more fond childhood memories of having pizza with my family (such as my folks, who've since passed). 🥰
My husband's from OK. He's not as much a fan of pizza as I (he's a "meat & potatoes" guy), but I don't hold it against him. 😉 Especially since Scrib's is HIS favorite. Second only to my homemade pizza, which he says is the best he's ever had (he's a keeper, I tell ya 🥰).
Unfortunately, I'm not physically able to cook anymore, so, when Friday comes 'round (which we call "pizza day", because we eat pizza most Fridays), I usually let him choose where we order it from. 9 times out of 10, he opts for Mr. Scrib's, of course. ☺️
Last night's pizza was a tad overbaked. It was still hot & DELICIOUS, though! So, if we could give half-stars, I might've rated it 4.5, but it doesn't deserve los
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Pizza
Toppings: onion, ham, bacon, ground beef, anchovies, pineapple, black olives, green olives, jalapeños, banana peppers, fresh garlic, tomato, mushroom, & sausage.
Subs
Dinners
French fries, roll and choice of coleslaw or applesauce.