I ordered a large NYC Style Cheese Pizza which came still hot and not greasy at all. Also ordered 12 boneless wings in the garlic parm flavor and it was crunchy, hot, and DELICIOUS! We are always looking for good pizza places and this one definitely is a top contender.
J
Jacob H
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 22/09/25
• DoorDash order
holy smokes. this NYC style pizza is unbelievably good. I'm pretty picky when it comes to pizza, and there's a lot of crappy pizza places in our area. Brooklyn Pizza is NOT one them. The crust is chewy but with a crispy bottom, and very little flop, with a fluffy, bubbly outer edge that begs to be dunked into garlic butter and eaten like bread sticks, when the cheese and sauce is all gone. The tomato sauce is lightly sweet, and seasoned perfectly to add the right balance of sweet and tangy. It tastes like it's made from scratch. The toppings taste fresh, and are piled on, making for a very hearty and filling pizza, but without being soggy or watery. I'm glad I decided to give them a try, and will 100% be ordering my pizza from them in the future.
The philly cheesesteak is also delicious,it tastes great, obviously uses quality meat, and is cooked perfectly. But the pizza is the real MVP.
S
Sarah V
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Loved
• 11/02/25
• DoorDash order
The Family cheese calzone is HUGE and sooo good, the Jalapeño poppers are the best I've had.! Love getting food from here. 10/10.
J
John D
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/04/26
• DoorDash order
My kids loved the pizza and bbq wings they didn't leave a crumb. This is not surprising, as Brooklyn Pizza has always excelled at preparing quality food! Also fair prices for excellent food.
N
Nikki H
1 contributions
Liked
• 1/02/25
• DoorDash order
Their garlic knots are fantastic - order them! Their thin crust pizza is great and toppings are good proportionally. Crust was well cooked and was a good ratio to toppings. We usually do not eat the crust part without the toppings, but found ourselves eating it all from here! I felt like the buffalo chicken pizza was lacking in flavor. I did not realize that it does not have a strong base flavor of blue cheese or ranch, so it felt bland to me. It had a good Buffalo flavor and decent amount of chicken but was a bit lack luster for me. I would try a different flavor next time.
