Butter Maid Bakery
4.6(200+)•
DashPass•
Bakery•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(200+)•
$$•Bakery
Butter Maid Bakery is a small family-owned and operated bakery in its fifth generation.
Since 2006, we've been distributing kolachi and other baked products from our bakery in Youngstown, Ohio, to all…
Full Menu
9:00 am–4:25 pmFeatured Items
US$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Chocolate Clothespin Cookies - Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns
US$25.99
Apple Crumb Pie - 9"
US$24.99
Clothespin Cookies Aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns
US$25.99
Raspberry Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles
US$25.99
Peanut Butter Buckeyes
US$19.99
Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll
US$19.99
Reviews200+ ratings • 7 public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
K
Kalah G
Emerging Expert • 8 contributionsLoved
• 23/12/24The M&M Chocolate Chip Mound was THE BEST cookie I've ever had!!! It's not fair I'm now going to have to continue purchasing these on a regular basis😂 The price is also amazing! I'm extremely grateful for the value and how delicious they are🥰
K
Kira S
3 contributionsLoved
• 2 days agoThis is my first time trying them, And I will be back!Birthday Cake Confetti Cookie is so good and they have amazing portions for there price
B
Brittany M
Emerging Expert • 15 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/01/24always loved this bakery for their Chocolate Chip Cookies but today was disappointed
maybe this is a new recipe as I haven't gotten them in a while but they don't look or taste like their original delicious chocolate chip cookies. they are hard and have white stuff on them which unfortunately we will not be finishing them. the picture on the menu compared to these is completely different. I also got the m&m giant cookie which looked and tasted like they use to.
K
Kristine D
3 contributionsDidn't like
• 11/01/24M&M Chocolate Chip Mound were hard as a rock! Could barely bite into them. Threw them out. what a disappointment. Regular Chocolate Chip Cookies were dry and flour-y. Chocolate Chocolate Chip Mound was nice and soft but mostly chocolate chips.
B
Brittany M
Emerging Expert • 15 contributionsDidn't like
• 7/01/24always loved this bakery for their Chocolate Chip Cookies but today was disappointed
maybe this is a new recipe as I haven't gotten them in a while but they don't look or taste like their original delicious chocolate chip cookies. they also have white spots on them so unfortunately we had to toss them. I also got the m&m giant cookie and that was the taste and look I remember.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Pies
Deep dish pies with our signature crispy crumb topping
Kolachi Nut Rolls
Cookie Boxes
Cookie Mounds
Insanely large and super rich cookies meant for the brave, or sharing.