Gino's NY Pizza
4.6(10k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(10k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Try the best pizzas in Buffalo to find a new favorite. Gino's NY Pizza has become one of the area's most popular restaurants. Try some of their offerings and see if you agree.Many Buffalo pizzerias se…
All Day
11:00 am–9:55 pmFeatured Items
US$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Whole Oreo Cheesecake
US$59.99
House 20" Cheese Pizza
US$27.99
•95% (254)
#3 most liked
Large 16" Cheese Pizza
US$21.99
•95% (567)
#1 most liked
Large 16" Pizza (1 Topping) & 10 Wings
US$39.50
•93% (119)
House 20" Pizza (1 Topping) & 10 Wings
US$44.50
•88% (9)
Wings (10)
US$17.99
•95% (242)
Reviews10k+ ratings • 200+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
M
Margaret D
Local Expert • 33 contributionsLoved
• 2/06/25Average Spaghetti Parm but the amount of cheese used was amazing They certainly didn't skimp. Pasta was done well. Sauce is a touch sweet but not too sweet with I appreciate. I got sausage which was kinda weird colored (really dark like meatless sausage) but tasted good. Added an order of meatballs which were definitely prepackaged but the sauce saved them. Dinner portion size is enough for 2. Garlic knots tasted a bit like lemon juice which was weird but the garlic balanced it out. Takes a while to prepare so this first if you're double dashing. I was craving spaghetti and Meatballs so this scratched that itch. All over satisfying and would order again.
K
Kelly B
Emerging Expert • 4 contributionsLoved
• 22/02/26The House 20" Cheese Pizza is consistently top tier, and the Stromboli is beyond delicious and consistent every time. This place is my favorite NY pizza joint around (coming from a downstate transplant).
A
Ashley R
3 contributionsLoved
• 17/05/25the stromboli was delicious. it was definitely enough for two meals and I am a pretty ambitious eater. the sauce that came with it by far exceeded my expectations, I don't usually care for red sauce but theirs is excellent and compliments without overpowering the stromboli. I will absolutely be ordering more from here and would highly recommend it whenever I can to as many as I can. very very good.
H
Hannah K
Emerging Expert • 20 contributionsLoved
• 4/07/24Chicken Parmesan (dinner) is enough to comfortably feed 2 very hungry people. It's slathered in delicious sauce and has some seriously epic cheese pull. Whenever I get it, it's steaming hot. My go-to comfort food. It's hard to choose between this and pizza, theyre both so good. Cannot recommend this place enough.
B
Bryan L
Local Expert • 24 contributionsLoved
• 8/09/25The Slice of Buffalo Chicken , Slice of Pepperoni and Slice of Cheese all held up strong. It's been a long time since I had Gino's since the Main Place Mall location, and back then- it didn't really hit for me that well.
This location for me, has been consistent every time. No slop jallop, chewy, crispy bottom, perfect balance of crust, cheese and sauce.
With that being said, my favorite was actually the Slice of Cheese... which is saying a lot. If the Cheese Slice can hold it's own above the rest? That's a solid pizzeria.
Had the stromboli and canollo on another order too. And both were very tasty, cooked to perfection. Very large stromboli, enough to eat in three sittings. The canollo was also filled with a ton of cream.
All in all, this has been my third order here- with many more likely to come. Again, consistency being key so far and what keeps me coming back.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Whole Cakes
Pre-order Your Favorite Cake at Least 24 Hour Notice !!!
NY Style Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Specialty Gluten Free Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Stuffed Pizza
Slices
Pizza & Wing Combos
Appetizers
Side Sauces
Salads
Side Orders
Wings, Fingers & Things
Calzones
All served with homemade marinara sauce, Ricotta, Mozzarella, and Romano cheeses in our homemade crust.
Italian Specialties
All served with homemade tomato sauce.
Hot Heroes
Cold Heroes
Steak Heroes
Chicken Heroes
Burgers
Tacos
Pasta
Served with three garlic knots.