Keystone is one of my favorite restaurants tosay, especially being from New York, myself. I will say the food is delicious, but for me the value can differ. I have ordered a lot of their sandwhiches and daily specials, but was extremely disappointed in the COPPA CUTLET CAPRESE today, due to price and size. all of the cutlet sandwiches arrive cut into 2 pieces and I always share with my son. the Coppa was by far the most expensive and while probably the best tasting sandwich, definitely much smaller. Luckily we ordered the SHAWARMA TOTS which were excellent by the way.
D
Dawn P
Local Expert • 64 contributions
Loved
• 13/10/26
• DoorDash order
I must go to this place twice a week, and I try something new every time. Since it's Tuesday, I decided to get the CHEESESTEAK which was so good. The sandwich is much larger than the other daily special sandwich with fresh mozzarella. I also got the POTATO SALAD, which is new. It was a good, but I almost wanna say it has mustard in it or something like that, which I'm OK with, but not my favorite. Very good.
D
Dawn P
Local Expert • 64 contributions
Liked
• 5/09/26
• DoorDash order
Have come several times, tried the special today, CHICKEN CAESAR GUTLET (SEEDED ROLL) and it was great, especially the seeded bun but i wish, there was more chicken on it. Being from New Yorj, it was a perfect thinly sliced fried chicken cutlet, IYKYK, but it didnt fit the bun, so 1/3 of sandwhich was just lettuce and dressing, but delicious. the SIDE FALAFEL (3) was probably the best I have had since leaving New York. So fresh, you can taste the feesh parsley. small complaint, wish the sauce was in container not just in the container with falafel, but still delicious. As usual the JERSEY TURNPIKE was perfection with the Taylor Pork. Worth it!
A
Aleesha J
Emerging Expert • 3 contributions
Loved
• 12/06/26
• DoorDash order
Absolutely love the TURKEY SAMMIE!!! The arugula is very fresh and crisp, the whole sandwich tastes so delicious, and the chipotle aioli adds a really great flavor! They give a great portion size, and the sourdough is also good size slices, not too thick and not too thin! I will definitely be ordering here again!! Thank you!!
J
Jackson A
6 contributions
Loved
• 5/09/25
• DoorDash order
Keystone has the best sandwiches period. I will order from here on just about any occasion. Perfect sized sandwiches as fresh as can be.
Keystone rocks!
