MAKER PIZZA - 171 Forest St
4.7(200+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(200+)•
Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am–9:40 pmFeatured Items
US$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Plain Cheese Pizza 16" (Round)
US$19.00
•91% (24)
#1 most liked
Beef Pepperoni Pizza 12" (Round)
US$15.00
Grandma Pie (Square)
US$27.00
Plain Cheese Pizza 12" (Round)
US$14.00
New York Style Margherita Pizza (Square)
US$24.00
Veggie Pizza 16" (Round)
US$25.00
Reviews200+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
J
Jenny N
1 contributionsLiked
• 5/07/25The Cheesecake was fantastic, as well as the red velvet cake. The Cheesesteak Egg Rolls (3) were perfectly crispy, and tasted good. I thought the Grilled Chicken stromboli had a wonderful dough, just enough cheese and filling, and the medium size is huge, enough for two. I thought the chicken itself could use more seasoning before adding it in, maybe more salt but overall tastes great and is made with real fresh ingredients. I would definitely order again.
H
Heather A
2 contributionsDidn't like
• 19/03/26Don't really like what we ordered - white pizza lacks some oomph. Not bad. Just not exciting. Garlic knots are adequate at best. The chicken fingers have an odd taste. I can imagine that this is the type of place you love or hate. No in between.
The order did get here warm and well packaged FWIW.
T
Tabby M
6 contributionsLoved
• 5/06/26The best pizza I've had in Montclair since I moved here 2 years ago. The beef pepperoni is fantastic. Definitely recommend!!
E
Elise P
Emerging Expert • 15 contributionsLoved
• 3/08/25Really delicious pizza. We tried the cheesesteak Stromboli and a custom margarita with ricotta, onion, and ground beef and it was all really delicious. Excellent crust and flavor. Kids loved it too!
J
Jay R
3 contributionsDidn't like
• 12/06/26We have gotten the Detroit style pizza many times and has been excellent.
This time however, the crust was burned badly.
This was burned badly enough that someone had to have smelled it before it was put into the box.
I get that mistakes happen and this was undoubtedly the case. However, this one should never have been sent to a customer.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Specialty Round 12" Pizza
Specialty Round 16" Pizza
Specialty Square Pizza
16" large.
Detroit Style Pizzas
Medium 12" size only.
Gluten Free Pizza
New. Medium 12" size only.
Strombolis
Stromboli: mozzarella and homemade pizza sauce. Calzone: mozzarella and ricotta cheese with a side of marinara.
Calzones
Fresh Salads
All salads are served with fresh ingredients, garlic knots and choice of dressing: blue cheese, Italian, French, balsamic vinaigrette, Caesar, oil & vinegar, ranch. Extra dressing, extra chicken for an additional charge.
Buffalo Wings
Served with celery & side of blue cheese or ranch. Choice of your favorite homemade sauce: hot, mild, BBQ, chipotle or honey BBQ.