Every restaurant has raised their prices but u sure get ur money's worth here. The Reuben best in the area. Could make 2 sandwiches out of the meat. Also best chili n chicken tortilla soup in the area.
T
Terri C
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
This the third time in as many weeks I have ordered the BLT + Avocado. I also paid for extra Avocado I never received. There was barely any avocado on any sandwich. I should have made a rating before this. I work in Merrillville and have ordered the same sandwich for lunch. There is so much avocado in makes the Highland sandwich look bare. Please pay more attention when extra avocado is ordered. The sandwich was delicious though I doubt I will order through door dash again. It'll only be pick up. I hope the staff will be understanding when I check it for extra avocado.
M
Marla L
Local Expert • 190 contributions
Loved
• 23/11/25
• DoorDash order
French Dip sandwiches were both very good. McAlister's Club Wrap was delicious, wish it could have been warmed up. Buffalo Chicken Spud was unbelievable!! This was the largest potato I have ever seen. Toppings were perfect.
R
Rachel M
24 contributions
Loved
• 28/01/23
• DoorDash order
Perfect in every single way. The bacon was fresh and hot. The avacado was green and fresh, the tomato was tender and not mushy, the garlic sauce was soooo good. The lettuce was crunchy and fresh. It fills you up too. 1000/10 highly recommend. Seriously.
J
Jacqueline W
40 contributions
Loved
• 1/02/22
• DoorDash order
Everything is most excellent as usual!! the southwest chicken sandwich and the tortilla soup and the potato salad is my absolute favorite! Ohh, and that tea, with the black cherry syrup, is so very very good... no place else has ever had that, and if they did, I wouldn't get it from them anyway I love McAlister's Deli Iced Tea!!💖💯💯💯
