I got the Reuben, really good solid sandwich with nice flavors. I would say I wish they added a bit more sauerkraut and thousand island, but that's just me. It was packed with meat though which is a huge plus! The potato salad was also quite nice. Ingredients seemed fresh, I'd order again.
Tammy W
Local Expert • 36 contributions
Loved
• 23/09/25
• DoorDash order
this is the best sandwich I've ever had and it doesn't even have meat in it. The size is perfect. I would definitely order this again. that cake is super fresh. the vegetables are crunchy and everything tastes amazing I Love it! this is my first impression
G
Grace S
7 contributions
Loved
• 12/12/24
• DoorDash order
The Veggie sandwich is delicious! The bread is soft and grainy, the vegetables taste fresh, and the herb mayo is very flavorful. The Justaspud® might seem expensive for just being a potato, but it's HUGE. It's like a two or three pound potato, and if you get it with cheese they are not shy with it. Their McAlister’s Famous Tea is also delicious. It's great on its own, but I tried the peach puree too, and it's absolutely delicious. The beverages in general are also a very reasonable size. I believe they are 32oz. Not $4 for a 16oz beverage full of ice like a lot of stores.
K
Kendra W
3 contributions
Loved
• 15/02/23
• DoorDash order
Best Deli I have ordered from in ages!! I travel for work and order way to frequently- this food was fantastic!! French Dip was great! And the Colossal Carrot Cake was huge, delicious and amazing with coffee for breakfast too.
J
Jack M
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/08/25
• DoorDash order
I've ordered from McAlister's before (the New Yorker was terrific), but the French Dip I got today was...disappointing. The beef was over cooked and dry, the Swiss cheese was barely there and also overcooked. Kudos to wrapping the Au Jus in plastic for delivery, but I won't be ordering this again.
