Discovered these cookies a year ago at a farmers market. LOVED them. So glad they got a store front. Ordered twice now. Don't care for the potato chip cookie. No crunch, just soggy potato chip chunks. But this was the only dud. They subbed the banana pudding cookies I ordered with strawberry, but they were amazing. This time, I got the banana ones. I can't decide if these or the Creme Brulee' are the best cookies I have ever eaten! OMG. The Snickerdoodles are also wonderful as are the mini chocolate chips. Perfect salt/sweet ratio. These are expensive, $5.50 each, but they are huge! I cut them in fours and eat over a few days. Best cookies in Houston, in Texas, heck perhaps the USA!
A
April M
3 contributions
Loved
• 9/02/23
• DoorDash order
These are the best cookies in Houston! Their Snickerdoodle and NutellaDream are my absolute favorites, but all of their flavors are delicious! I have placed a few large group orders for myself and my nurse coworkers, and our orders have all been packaged with care. Thank you, Milk Mustache!
N
Nefre N
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Loved
• 2/05/25
• DoorDash order
Campfire Bliss is exactly that—pure bliss! Fresh, beautifully packaged, with that dreamy marshmallow pull and perfectly chewy texture. Just the right hit of sweet satisfaction. Officially my new favorite cookie!
Steve C
Emerging Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 29/04/25
• DoorDash order
These cookies taste better than they look, and that's saying a lot because their presentation is on point! Seems like cookie joints are popping up everywhere, but hands down no comparison to Milk Mustache. Yes I've tried most of the others... E for effort but no comparison
C
Chris R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/07/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the 1 dozen. The cookies were all a bit over baked. I wouldn't say anything, but if I'm paying almost $70.00 for cookies, I don't want them over baked. I'm sure they're delicious!
