Good sandwich making is an art form. The staff at Mr. Pickle make excellent sandwiches. Moist enough to hold things together. Just the right proportions on each sandwich. I think these 3 sandwiches are the best I have ever had. I have always loved Mr. Pickle. Tonight was the BEST!
J
Jeannette P
Local Expert • 123 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/09/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered the kids turkey sandwich meal. This is the second time they made the sandwich with the heel of the bread and the piece next to it. Both were thick and dry. The turkey was minimal as was the lettuce and tomato. I have ordered this a few times over the years and loved that it was fresh and well made. No more.
H
Harry S
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Loved
• 24/08/26
• DoorDash order
These sandwiches never fail to delight my buds! Theyare packed tightly with meats, veggies, and nourishing ingredients. I always know that I will be getting freshness guaranteed and a terrific meal.
C
Candice B
Emerging Expert • 31 contributions
Didn't like
• 29/08/26
• DoorDash order
Eh, plenty of meat. Au jus had little flavor. Way too much horseradish mayo. The pork sandwich tasted like reheated meant. Maybe my tastebuds are just changing. It was quality food, just didn't taste good to me :(
W
William G
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
Didn't like
• 19/02/25
• DoorDash order
This was the most disappointing sandwich I've ever gotten from Mr Pickles. I ordered my favorite, a Goomba with added cucumber, and received a sandwich overloaded with ham and scarcely anything else. Scant amounts of the other meats and one slice of cucumber on each end of the sandwich (which wasn't cut). My husband was even less impressed with his and didn't finish it for the first time ever. Even the cookies (which are usually fantastic) were burnt and dry. Very sad. We've only ever had one other experience even close to this, and it was also for an order placed in the evening. Seems the afternoons are a safer bet!