My Tomato Pie
4.6(2k+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
4.6(2k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am–7:40 pmFeatured Items
US$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Pasta Maria
US$29.70
•86% (15)
Large 16" Pizza
US$27.50
•90% (134)
#1 most liked
Large Sicilian
US$30.80
Chicken Parmesan
US$29.70
•96% (32)
Cheese Ravioli
US$24.20
•90% (20)
Mac & Cheese
US$22.00
•100% (23)
Reviews2k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
K
Kristen S
2 contributionsLoved
• 14/01/25The Personal Pizza is a great size for a lunch or light dinner. Personal Sergio is a really good mix of flavors and textures. 10/10 would get again.
A
Alexis T
Local Expert • 34 contributionsLoved
• 23/11/24Vegetable Minestrone Soup Bowl is alright. Not that big of a bowl. Cajun Zesty Chicken Pasta is pretty good, I liked it. They use blackened chicken so you're going taste that char smokey taste on it. Slightly dry but good. My favorite thing is the Lemon Chicken Pita Sandwich. Banana peppers in it are a must. It's a delicious sandwich!
M
Michelle B
87 contributionsLoved
• 28/01/26I have ordered the same calzone probably 20 times and this is the first time I actually received extra mozzarella as ordered Best calzone I had there so far. Large portion size fresh ingredients. I would order again 
E
Erica S
12 contributionsLoved
• 11/07/25I am very happy with the recent spaghetti & meatballs, I had for my meal today. Tony & Dawn went out of their way to make me a very Happy Customer. Who will return. The sauce was homemade and one of the best in the Amherst/N.Tonawanda areas. The spinach and cheese bread was crisp and mouth watering tasty! I highly recommend.
O
Orson R
Emerging Expert • 4 contributionsLiked
• 30/03/25Overall very good, pizza cooked just right! Fingers were saucy yet crisp, onion rings fried just right. Def would order again
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store