Nina's Pizza in Utica, NY, is located on Historic Genesee St and is sure to please. On Fridays, they serve only the tastiest fish, with daily specials. An authentic Italian restaurant to whet your app…
The mozzarella Sticks are amazing you get 6 of them and they're nice and warm! Love! The pizza never fails!
S
Sandy F
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 16/10/23
• DoorDash order
Very dissatisfied with how few fried dough bites we got for price (9 little pieces) and they were cold. Chicken Riggies had no flavor and were not very spicy for medium tasted more like roasted sweet peppers which were in there and would have thought atleast a few banana peppers but none. Tuna sub was great flavor wise but was very damp and soggy(as seen from glisten on bread) and don't order extra toppings as there were none even though u pay for them. Also the cheese was thick enough to make a great grilled cheese with that I had to remove it as was a thick piece for biting (in my opinion)
K
Kat K
23 contributions
Liked
• 15/06/25
• DoorDash order
Food always arrives nice and hot! Spaghetti with meatsauce was very flavorful . The meat sauce is basically mini meatballs through out the pasta (which is a plus for me). Portion is huge, def couldnt finish in one sitting. Would happily order this again! 10 Wings were crispy and great as always! Try the hot mixed with butter and garlic!
E
Evan R
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Liked
• 28/05/26
• DoorDash order
The riggies are just pasta with sauce . Not riggie sauce. Not traditional riggies. It's good & I order often but it's always inconsistent, you never know the flavor you'll get. For the price it's not worth it. Portions are perfect though & it always comes hot.
V
Vincent D
1 contributions
Loved
• 18/01/26
• DoorDash order
nina's seems to offer the only vegan upside pizza in the mohawk valley. honestly, it was quite delicious.
mods: upside down, vegan cheese, extra sauce, crispy (i'll probably go 'extra crispy' next time).
their standard vegan pizza wasn't bad, but the upside down vegan leaves the classic pie in the dust.
if you're vegan or lactose intolerant, nina's is your pizzeria. will definitely order this bad boy again.
