They keep sending regular garlic sauce when I order spicy garlic sauce. After the second time, I deducted a star. Otherwise no complaints about Parmesan Crusted Papadias. They are my favorite menu item. I always order the "create your own" option since I don't like the default selections. I am happy they don't charge extra for every topping, like most places do, which is a rip-off. They just limit the number, which is reasonable. I like the fresh baked brownies. Wish the had milk for my dessert. I wouldn't mind a salad on the menu, but a double dash order can take care of that I guess.
N
Noah D
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/04/26
• DoorDash order
more like chicken nuggets. They tasted really salty and were pretty soggy. The portion was as advertised and I didn't get any overly breaded pieces. they were warm when I got them so seemed fresh enough it was the only place delivering at the time so I guess I would order again. BBQ Boneless WingsGarlic Parmesan Boneless Wings
C
Courtland B
1 contributions
Loved
• 16/02/24
• DoorDash order
Everything was cooked properly. Packaging was much better than others. Im very impressed with Papa John's. This is my second order with Papa John's. I had bad experiences with a small Italian pizza company. Im sticking with the Papa.
A
Arijana O
2 contributions
Liked
• 13/08/25
• DoorDash order
The Create Your Own Pizza was good and so were the Cinnamon Pull Aparts. But getting half a container of icing for 1.19 is a ripoff
K
Kimi M
2 contributions
Loved
• 9/03/25
• DoorDash review
My dad lives in Buffalo in an area that's not close to much, but DoorDash delivers papajohns to him. Once a driver accidentally mixed up his delivery and the driver called PJs, they sent out a new pizza! Love this store! Being in WA trying to get my elderly parent a pizza this made me really appreciate this store!
