The Mt. Sinai store has been my favorite for over 15 years. Everything is fresh and so delicious. Recently, I ordered once from the one in Selden and their cheese was GOOD. If Mt. Sinai store used the same cheese...they would be even more unstoppable.
N
Natasha T
5 contributions
Loved
• 30/06/23
• DoorDash review
Door Dash and service from Papa John top notch in service and quality. A great delivery service used when working over nights at Mather Memorial Northwell Health Jefferson. Arrival hot and steamy. Incredibly tasty. Topping gator,,, affordable and worth the price. Keep it leveled when driving in supportive case to keep HOT.
Engineering team Business to Business Top performance in service safe handling QUALITY 100% products
5Star
M
Melissa G
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 11/04/22
• DoorDash order
Papa John's is the only pizza I like on Long Island. My favorite is the Hawaiian bbq chicken. Who says pineapple doesn't go on pizza. <3. I also recommend bacon and pineapple with the 3 cheese blend. Perfect combo of sweet and salty.
R
Rob H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/07/26
• DoorDash order
Normally Theyre great! But had an issue this time with it being stale when it came. It tasted very bland and just wasnt okay to serve to customers. Hope this was a one time thing. Disappointing.
A
Angie w
3 contributions
Loved
• 6/04/26
• DoorDash order
The Super Hawaiian Pizza is so good and so fresh. I am definitely going to order thid again. I ordered two smalls but I wish i got more. Do not knock hawaiian pizza before you try it because its so amazing