Over a decade of coming here and absolutely every Chicken Parmigiana has been the same perfection. Traveled back from TX and they are my first meal, first day when I hit NJ. I'll have it at least one more time for the Italian and might get one for the flight back- it's really that good.
N
Nancy D
95 contributions
Didn't like
• 27/09/26
• DoorDash order
I love writing great positive happy reviews. Unfortunately this one isn't one of those as this food was just awful. Terrible "shrinkflation" aside it was jus not good. And that's putting it nicely. Avoid these overpriced, minuscule so-called Philly Cheesesteak Hubby said there was barely any meat, needed a microscope to find the Cheese on Philly Cheesesteak Mine however, was a no cheese sandwich on purpose which is great but unfortunately my meat was all DRIED OUT. No flavor also on these two steaks. What also really upsets us too is the fact that we *love fried onions* so like what in the green hell happened here? One string people. One skinny string. That was the extent of our *extra* "fried onions" that we ordered n paid very well for too lol SMH. We ordered double onions. Huh? Seriously Primo? You should change your name to "NOPE". BORING and DRY. Thank goodness I had some chopped onions from ACME n my fridge that I cooked N fried up with olive oil, pink sea salt n pepper. It made it edible. On a happier note I did enjoy The Primo Pilgrim that was nice unique take on a the typical Gobbler. I liked that one n thanks for making me feel a little bit less ripped off. Loved the extra cranberry! YAY! Nice People notice especially nowadays so yeah those Philly Cheesesteak were way overpriced and extremely underwhelming at best. Hey the Herr's Kettle OriginalHerr's Ripples SC & Onion really were delicious tho n we added ketchup N mustard. You lost a longtime customer being serving us that mess. Sorry but it's true. Avoid.
N
Nancy D
95 contributions
Loved
• 26/08/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was really great wow YUM! The meat was super tender, no fat, super fluffy n those sesame seeds n the rolls were delicious too... Loved the cold Turkey & Cheese one too, n Whacked Chicken n Chicken Parmigiana just wonderful and full of flavor!!! Thank you will order again soon thank you also to our Dasher William
R
Renee D
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 29/06/25
• DoorDash order
The Soprano is really good but could use a few more roasted peppers. The Corned Beef Schwartzie was great. This Primos always does a great job.
D
Dominique D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 15/09/24
• DoorDash order
Not impressed. I usually love primo. This time we ordered 2 things out of the norm... the bada boom had 1 long hot on the whole sandwich. Disappointed.
We also ordered the Crusher and it had 2 stuffed peppers cut in half and the guts of the pepper were missing out of one.
Primos usually does better. Not happy tonight though.
