The Sabrina is the best ice can sandwich I've ever had. Ate it so quickly that I forgot to take a pic! It was much smaller than expected but packed with flavor! Very unique flavors. Same goes for the Aquarius Cake (Lemon Blueberry Tiramisu). I've never had anything like it. Will continue ordering this sweet and sharp indulgence.
K
Kendal M
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/02/26
• DoorDash order
Hot damn, these icecream sandwiches are divine! The flavor combinations are spectacular and unique. My favorite right now is the Alina! The lemon ice cream with gingerbread cookie is delicious. 10/10, you should try this wonderful shop!
J
Jennifer H
Local Expert • 165 contributions
Loved
• 8/09/25
• DoorDash order
First time ordering! Wasn't quite sure what to expect but the buy one get one deal made me finally try it. I really enjoyed both the Virgo Ice Cream Cake and the Quentin (v+/gf). Both were fresh, tasty, and intriguing. Portion size of the Virgo Ice Cream Cake was more than enough and the Quentin (v+/gf) was just right. The packaging is cute too, and it comes in an insulated bag to keep cool. I would order again for sure!!
L
Liz P
1 contributions
Loved
• 17/08/25
• DoorDash order
ordered some gideon Hexes and sugarwitch quickly reached out to me to let me know they were actually out of that particular flavor and if they could get me anything else. i got ursula Hexes instead (along with an Ice Pack!) and was delighted with them. we love trying new witches and the portion sizes of the Hexes makes that easy. we will definitely order again! delicious as always <3
A
Ashle G
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Loved
• 26/07/24
• DoorDash order
Ice cream sandwiches are one of my favorite foods ever. Finding out I'm gluten intolerant has made it difficult to find a good ice cream sandwich that doesn't make me ill. The Cruela is gluten free and it's delicious! The super cute packaging is an added bonus. I would recommend Sugar Witch!
