Tony's NY Pizza - Marco Island
4.7(500+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(500+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Authentic New York style pizza. A slice of NY in Marco.
Founded by Tony (from the Bronx), we bring a taste of New York to Southwest Florida by serving authentic NY style pizza.
We only use high q…
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Cheese Pie
$17.99
•87% (48)
#1 Most liked
18" 1/2 & 1/2
$25.99
•87% (8)
The Park Ave. Margherita
$23.99
•75% (8)
14" 1/2 & 1/2
$23.99
The Staten Island
$23.99
The Queens White
$23.99
•100% (8)
Reviews500+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
S
Susan A
1 contributionsLiked
• 8/4/26Oh my gosh - SOOOO good! We ordered a cheese pizza, side of meatballs and small Caesar. We can't say how much we loved this meal. We just wanted to stay in one of our nights on vacation and watch a movie. The meatballs which I'm so picky about, are so big and so EXCELLENT!! And the pizza is like old-school NY pizza. We reheated for a few minutes and perfect!. We have five days left on our trip and I have a feeling we will be back to Tony's. Such an excellent authentic Italian tasting meal and the price SO extremely reasonable. Even our delivery person was so great. I felt terrible because I forgot you couldn't get into the lot without a parking pass and he actually walked it all the way into us to meet us at the lobby (earned himself a double tip). This has become a highlight of our week!!
C
Cullen B
3 contributionsLoved
• 11/24/24Best NY style pizza around. Big chains cannot compare. Great for a grab-and-go slice, and a decent price considering everything is made fresh. Always tastes great! Staff is super friendly and accommodating. Even though I can somewhat taste the difference between the regular and Gluten Free crush, it's a great option for those who are Gluten Free/intolerant
I
Ivan S
Emerging Expert • 19 contributionsLoved
• 9/19/24This pizza was pretty good. The crust had a good taste, it was end to end cheese and sauce. Large slices. Really lives up to its name. The side salad was plentiful and nice cuts of fresh veggies. The garlic knots were good as well. Loved it.
E
Elisabeth T
3 contributionsLoved
• 9/15/24Beat NY style pizza since I have been in NY! We requested a special request with our wings and the establishment was kind enough to add a hand written note apologizing the request could not be met. Amazing customer service!!!
D
David B
3 contributionsLoved
• 2 days agoBest Pizza on Marco... hands down. Great price, always fresh, portions are correct. I'm ordering right now
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Create a Pie
Toppings: pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham, bacon, mushroom, green pepper, banana pepper, roasted red pepper, jalapeño, onion, garlic, spinach, basil, tomato, pineapple, olives, ricotta, buffalo mozzarella, feta, extra cheese, balsamic reduction, buffalo sauce, ranch, BBQ sauce, chicken, eggplant, anchovies, extra sauce for an additional charge.
Tony's New York Pies
Pizza by the Slice
Calzones & Strombolis
Add toppings for an additional charge.
Appetizers
Soup
Salads
Classic Italian Subs
All subs served on a sesame seeded baguette. No substitutions.
Italian Dinners
Served with a small house salad.
Beverages
Desserts
Sides
Sauces & Dressings
Pizza Dough
Our 16" and 18" pizza dough balls for homemade pizzas