I would order from 3 Men & A Bagel when they were at cedar crest. Sad when they closed. Ordered from Manhattan and sorry but they don't compare. Liked that I could request special bagel. I like my turkey on a raisin bagel with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomatoes with mayo. Been eating that for years. Their bagels taste good, fresh, portion of meat is good. If you're looking for a new flavor. Chips and a dill pickle come with the sandwich too. Try this combo that is my own recipe. Or be adventurous and pick your fav bagel, fav meat and cheese and put them altogether. See what you come up with. Thumbs up!
P
Percival Toadwell V
Local Expert • 20 contributions
Liked
• 2/1/26
• DoorDash review
3 Men and a Bagel — Filed by Percival Toadwell Van Bristow
3 Men and a Bagel is not here to fool around. It knows exactly what it is doing and does it with confidence. I take the egg and cheese on an onion bagel—a combination that delivers a proper texture adventure: chew, softness, a little bite, all playing in the same key.
The onion bagel brings a low, savory note, the egg stays tender, the cheese behaves itself, and the whole affair lands with a balance that feels planned, not lucky. Their sesame bagel also deserves mention - well-seeded, well-baked, and very much on the level.
This is bagel work with backbone. No flop, no false chew, no empty promises. Just good structure and honest satisfaction.
I finished mine without a crumb spared and no regrets worth reporting.
Five stars. These fellows know their holes, and they fill them admirably.
- Percival Toadwell Van Bristow
A
Abishek E
2 contributions
Liked
• 3/30/26
• DoorDash order
I got multiple onion,egg, garlic, everything and jalapeno bagels. All of them are fabulous and my LehighValley favorites. They arrived fresh and would satisfy one bagel a person or even two!
M
Madeline B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/12/26
• DoorDash order
My husband's Blazing Buffalo Chicken Melt Sandwich was excellent. He claimed, "They've perfected it!"
Meanwhile, I was excited for an Egg & Cheese Sandwich on an everything bagel. The bagel, itself, was delicious. But as I went to "share" some egg with my toddler, I noticed it was discolored and smelled off. Never had a poor food item or experience with 3 Men and a Bagel...and sad this was the case today.
L
Lisa C
15 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/26/26
• DoorDash order
When I saw Taylor ham I thought of Taylor pork roll and yes when it arrived it looked like spam or pork roll. Suggest real sliced ham and a little extra in the sandwich. The bagels are thick and with so little meat all I tasted was the bagel and mustard. I ordered 2 sandwiches and 2 drinks and should have had 2 pickles and 2 bags of chips. Only received 1 of each. I'll still order again because I love my turkey on a raised I ordered the other day.
