If you are debating on trying their Calzone - Single Item ; this is your sign: DO IT. It is literally the best calzone ive had in YEARS! And you can't beat the price for the quality of these ingredients and the huge portion size!
R
Robert G
82 contributions
Loved
• 2/11/26
• DoorDash order
Absolutely perfect as always. Great size for the price, freshest ingredients (I believe from their own garden) and the best margherita pizza in central Ohio. Today's pie was sincerely divine and worth every red cent.
D
Darren C
Local Expert • 35 contributions
Loved
• 5/8/26
• DoorDash order
In Reynoldsburg (or this entire area of suburban Columbus in general) this pizza is far and away the only REAL pizza you will find. The crust is absolutely perfect, and you can see the perfect char on the undercarriage.
While Dave Portnoy is one of the dumbest people in existence, someone needs to get him to come out to Tyler's and try a 3-Cheeses BeGeezus, because he would almost certainly give them an 8.8 at the bare minimum, and the influx of new customers would be something this shop 100% deserves.
10/10 pizza, I'll stop by today at lunch and try the calzone; which I'm sure will be just as amazing.
R
Ross K
2 contributions
Loved
• 3/15/25
• DoorDash order
One of my fav pizza joints! The Paupers pie is amazing! Love the sour dough pizza base! Will definitely be ordering from here going forward!
S
Susan O
24 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/6/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza arrived cold. Crust was terrible, mushy towards the middle of the pie, but burnt on the bottom. Tasted like I was eating charcoal. One of the worst pizzas I've ever had.
