Gatto's Pizza started off as a modest store on North High Street in the Clintonville district of Columbus, Ohio. In 1952, brothers Joe and Jimmy Gatto started the pizzeria to serve their town, making …
I grew up on Gatto's Pizza, so I have lots to compare it to, but my order this evening was one of the all-time BEST pizzas ever. It was perfectly baked, with tons of REAL PEPPERONI, incredible sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. No hyperbole, just an unexpected reminder that great pizza can still be found in Columbus.
C
Connie O
Local Expert • 92 contributions
Loved
• 6/18/25
• DoorDash order
This was our first time ordering from this place. We ordered a 15" pepperoni extra cheese and extra sauce... crust is crispy thin... delicious pizza. The salad was amazing love the homemade Italian dressing. Thanks:)
M
Miriam K
Emerging Expert • 26 contributions
Loved
• 12/16/22
• DoorDash order
This might be my new favorite pizza joint! Love the crisp cups of the classic pepperoni and sliced sausage vs. crumbled
C
Colin H
1 contributions
Liked
• 2/7/26
• DoorDash order
I've been getting pizza here for years and can confidently say this is the best pizza in Clintonville! The crispy curly pepperonis and perfectly cooked crust never disappoints!
M
Marlena P
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/7/25
• DoorDash order
The sauce is not great. Little to sweet for my taste. Portion size was massive, though. Too much seaon the bread.
