Smokin' Barrel BBQ is a family-owned and operated dining experience. Established in 2016 by Mike and CJ McFarland as a backyard competition, Smokin' Barrel BBQ has become Central Indiana's new savory …
They were out of Baked Beans. Darn. Didn't get them last time other. Must be very good but this time I was refunded and giving every side on the menu plus a hand written note plus banana pudding. Plus enough Pulled Pork Dinner to feed two people. I have over 5 sides and only played for 3. Plus pudding. If I could kiss you guys I would. Love you. Can't wait to meet y'all!!
P
Pamela L
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/24/26
• DoorDash order
I'm a BBQ LOVER. To me, GOOD BBQ, doesn't NEED sauce, it's a WANT. Most smoked BBQ is seasoned while being smoked, and NOT AFTER. These tips had SO MUCH pepper sprinkled on them INSIDE the tray, that I couldn't finish them, they were TOO SPICY/HOT. I literally had to dip in sauce, then take a drink of water . Tips were cut too thick, for my liking, and there's no where on site to ask for thin / center cut. The Mac n cheese was AWESOME! The baked beans, NOT SO MUCH! They had too much of something. Palates couldn't decipher, due to the taste of the tips. They just weren't good. Everything was packaged good, though. A pound of tips gone to waste, cause I CAN NOT finish these things.
X
Xaviera K
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Liked
• 5/7/26
• DoorDash order
the texture of the potato in the potato salad is weird today
