Have ordered again and again! Their slice of cheese is the best, and absolutely humongous (their one slice is about the size of 2-3 slices from other places). Freshness overload, this is now my go-to place for pizza. So good!
D
Deatrice C
4 contributions
Loved
• 4/27/26
• DoorDash order
Order came super quick considering the 28inch half cheese / half mushroom pie was huge! For the size and quantity of pizza, it was well worth the price. No way one person can eat all that by themselves, definetly a meal for 2+. By far, the best pizza place to get more bang for your buck if you're looking for a pizza fix to satisfy your craving for days. I rate Benny's Capolago's 4.8 stars only because there was no drink options on the DoorDash app to order fountain drinks, tea, or other beverages, at least not that I saw. The quantity, taste, authenticity, and freshness of the pizza I rate 9:10. The only thing that could have made this pizza better was to add some truffles to the mushroom half and it would have been a slam dunk 10:10 going on a 1,00 with a TKO to Wegmans Mushroom Truffle pizza taking down the opponent with no chance of a rematch. However in this case, Wegmans Mushroom Truffle pizza sillls reigns supreme on originality and taste but Benny Capolago's dominated in every other area hands down. I highly recommend all pizza lovers to give this Resturant a try and be prepared to be blown away. Thanks, D. Crawley!
J
Jim K
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/28/25
• DoorDash order
Sauce is weird to me to be honest. Id describe as a descent bowling alley pizza
J
Jack D
1 contributions
Liked
• 11/9/25
• DoorDash order
Great pizza but fairly lame no drinks available for purchase on delivery, otherwise 5 stars.
