Carmelo’s
4.7(10k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(10k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Delicious PIZZA & SUBS Whether you are on the run or want to relax, Carmelo’s Marketplace Pizzeria offers Saint Augustine, an exciting and enticing menu of the highest quality. Carmelo’s Marketplace P…
Full Menu
11:00 am - 10:35 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
20" Pepperoni Pizza
$25.28
20" Cheese Pizza
$22.53
Jumbo Wings
$16.48
16" Carmelo's Supreme Pizza
$28.58
16" Pepperoni Pizza
$21.43
16" Cheese Pizza
$19.23
Reviews10k+ ratings • 100+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
A
Ann R
4 contributionsLoved
• 6 days agoStromboli We have had Carmelo's before, and they NEVER disappoint! Their stromboli has the BEST crispy, buttery, and flavorful outer crust with a melty, cheesy, garlicy middle that is just bursting with all the deliciousness of the best Italian pizza🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤯
The Chef Salad was pretty decent, and the blue cheese dressing was better than store bought🤤
S
Saad N
2 contributionsLoved
• 6/21/26Best pizza spot in Florida that I've tried, up to this point, while being priced extremely fair. This is coming from someone who was born and raised in Philly, into my father and uncle's pizzeria business of over 30 years. With a total of 13 locations at one point, but now sold and retired for a long time. The dough is mixed and proofed to perfection, creating an airy yet chewy crust, and an immaculate fold to the slice. The sauce has the perfect amount of tang, while offering the full robustness of the tomatoes, and a dash of sweet. The toppings are top tier and fresh, making any choice a home run. The same goes for the calzones and strombolis, using the same dough and ingredients, if you're wanting that instead of a pizza. The choices for appetizers are exactly what I would hope to be offered from a pizzeria. I'm a sucker for cream cheese jalepeno poppers, and they do not disappoint. They have a deliciously crisp bite to them, while oozing out a savory cream cheese and softness of the mild jalepeno. I imagine the other appetizers would hit on the same level of satisfaction, seeing that they proudly choose premium products for all of their items on the menu. I have yet to dabble into their pasta dishes, but have seen what they put out. Based on what I've seen, the portions are more than generous, and I have to imagine they uphold their same standards of deliciousness. I will be trying a few, the next time I visit with my children. Oh, speaking of children, all 3 of them (5, 8, 13) said it was the best pizza they ever had. When a kid is also on board, and not comparing it to the processed crap coming from the main franchises that most kids prefer, that's saying something! Anyways, if you're thinking about this place, just pull the trigger and order whatever you're in the mood for, because I can't see anything but deliciousness and bellies satisfied happening afterwards... and maybe a little well deserved food coma nap. Oh, one more thing, you get the wonderful bonus of having an extremely friendly group of people working there, that make you feel like family, and wanting to come back just for the sweet interaction of picking up and checking out. Nothing else I could really say. Customer for life. 10/10
S
Saad N
2 contributionsLoved
• 7/7/26Best pizza and anything else you'd hopefully expect from a pizzeria, in Florida, that I've tried to this point. No flop, only perfect fold and hold. Toppings are premium and fresh. Dough is perfectly proofed, giving a good crunch and airiness, but also the chewiness you would like after those first couple chews. You cannot go wrong with this place, if you're looking for a good pizzeria menu. Also, the entrees aren't anything to joke about. They will fill you up, with the same premium quality I expect from anything here. 10/10, just order it, if you're even thinking about it. You will be very happy, I can promise you that. The bonus is the staff are always extremely kind and catering to whatever you need, within the limits of common respect and decency, of course. Hope you all enjoy, the way my family and I always do.
J
Joseph B
20 contributionsLoved
• 3/28/26As usual, Carmelo’s comes through once again. They are awesome years. I've never had a problem tonight. I had Italian style chicken wings again and they have the best ones in the area.
Joseph B
 Thank you Tim for Keeping the place awesome, and you have a great day 
J
John J
1 contributionsLoved
• 6/7/24The homemade meat lasagne & spaghetti with meatballs are tremendous; they're very large servings & very delicious & well made. This is about the third time we've ordered this meal from Carmelo's and we'll continue to order it; it's that good!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store