During the week of Jan 13-20th a coworker of mine purchased a 4-pack during his break and brought it back to work. He told me had something for me and allowed me to try one of my first Crumbl Cookies. I had seen many posts and heard about the business but just didn't see my self going out to try one because I didn't want to end up disappointed.I decided to go with the Strawberry Cupcake which was delightful.
Then last week he went in again only this time He let me choose all 4 options for another 4 pack he was going to order. I decided to give the new Cinnamon Square a shot (really good just a bit too much frosting and not enough cinnamon in my opinion), the Strawberry Crumb Cake, Peanut Butter with Reese's (a crowd favorite am off ng coworkers) , ANDDD Cookies & Creme which was amazing 😍. Even better when we warmed it up in Vero Amore's brick oven!!!
All I can say is, I think I may be getting hooked on these because I just ordered my first 4 pack!
This one is pretty simple because I'm sharing it with my son and I know what kind of cookies he likes. Next order will be a bit more spontaneous....Also the whole time I was ordering I was wondering to myself, 'I wonder which mystery cookie is at this location 🧐'. Til next time Crumbl 🍪
G
Geena K
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Liked
• 10/20/25
• DoorDash order
Crumbl is trying to do too much in my opinion. The pumpkin square was my favorite (once I scraped the thick layer of icing off), but it was more of a bread than anything resembling a cookie. The strawberry milk cookie and the Twix cookie were 3/10 and 5/10 respectively for me, tasted like something you could get at Safeway. The peanut butter chocolate chip cookie, fire, 10/10. The food is always fresh, but some of these flavors just do too much.
S
Savonna M
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/23/25
• DoorDash order
all the cookies were extremely raw. The chocolate one didn't even seem like it was cooked at all just pure dough.
E
Emaleigh Z
3 contributions
Liked
• 1/16/25
• DoorDash order
Have order a couple weeks ago and the French toast cook was delicious. Ordered this week and 2 of 3 cookies were undercooked. Little diappointing because I was excited for the cookies this week but flavor is 10/10.
J
Jovanna O
9 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/11/24
• DoorDash order
That blue cook aint it. M & M's cookie for the win, cho chip is always a safe bet, not worth price the price for these flavors.
