At Five Star Pizza, we are passionate about our pizzas. We work relentlessly to source the best possible ingredients, regardless of cost. From our Wisconsin mozzarella cheese to our California fresh p…
Ordered yesterday and today both times around 1am and they still nailed it. Pizza looks good and topping amount is good; by the looks of it they use the same bread for the cinnamon bites and the garlic bread, it's just different sauces tossed on top but either way both were really good. Good food helps hold off sad thoughts. Thanks for making it so late into the night still.
J
Justin L
13 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/1/24
• DoorDash review
How's it possible to be worse than Gas Station Pizza? The sauce was flavorless, the dough was chewy like microwaved Wonder bread, and the pepperoni tasted like it came out of the back of a freezer from 1982. this place used to be really close to being New York Pizza, and someone internally has purposely sabotaged this pizza place into the dumpster. The reason why they get one star review? They have the audacity to super overcharge you for thdi dumpster pizza more than any of the other competitors on doordash. You will never get my hard-earned blue-collar money again.
S
Shay N
2 contributions
Loved
• 5/30/25
• DoorDash order
This my second time ordering from them in 2 days lol! Their pizza is SOOOOO GOOD! My new pizza place for sure! Plus, they're the most kindest people ever! Every time I go to pick up, they are just so friendly and funny! If you havent tried Five Star , you NEED to! I now know why they're called Five Star Pizza!
M
Mariah D
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 1/1/26
• DoorDash order
The All the Meats pizza was exactly what I was craving. Every slice was hearty, well balanced, and full of flavor without being overwhelming. The toppings were generous, the crust held up perfectly, and it stayed delicious even after cooling down. Five Star Pizza did not miss with this one. Would absolutely order again.
N
Nanci R
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/17/25
• DoorDash order
PEPPERONI ROLLS were good, but 1 of the orders was rolled very short and thick, causing the inside to be filled with raw dough. The other order of rolls were great, much thinner and cooked through.
They sat in garlic butter. It would be better to brush it on top so the bottoms stay crispy.
