Goodfellas Pizzeria
4.4(200+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.4(200+)•
Pizzeria
Authentic hand-tossed NY-style pizza, calzones, and more in Cincinnati's Pleasant Ridge neighborhood.
Full Menu
11:00 am - 10:10 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
16" Pie
$22.00
•83% (31)
#1 Most liked
12" Pie
$16.00
•75% (29)
#2 Most liked
16" Half & Half Pie
$22.00
•83% (12)
Calzone
$13.00
•64% (17)
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Bread
$19.00
•61% (13)
Cheese Bread
$15.00
Reviews200+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.4
of 5 stars
A
Alexa A
1 contributionsLoved
• 7/29/26Excellent pizza and breadsticks every single time
N
Nanette C
4 contributionsLoved
• 6/13/26This is one of the best calzones I have ever eaten. The bread is tasty, the fillings are exactly what I wanted. The chicken is very well seasoned and there is a generous amount of it, too. Great food!
J
Jenay N
4 contributionsDidn't like
• 1/9/26Pendleton Housing - 610 Reading Rd
I am not one to post negative reviews. I feel like we all have a bad day but it's not like Goodfellas to have poor quality food. I'm hoping this review will be constructive criticism and not taken as an insult.
I order often for my company a couple blocks away, so I know this isn't their norm
This time the pizza was undercooked. The veggies were not warm. It's almost like the veggies & meat were added at the end.
The bread on the buffalo chicken cheese bread was dough because it was undercooked as well. That wasn't the only w/ 2 large orders of the bread. It's obvious that it's sat for a while although I can see the driver was there immediately to pick up the food. It didn't take long he would arrived within 35 to 40 minutes, but it just wasn't the same.
It was an off day and I hope it was a one time occurrence because we really enjoy their food!
When you order from DoorDash, they changed the price so one large pizza and two orders of the buffalo chicken and cheese bread and six drinks was $128!
I hate to put out that kind of money if the quality is bad. I did not see pictures I had because it was obvious I even looking at it before we even ate. Otherwise thank you Goodfellas for typically having excellent.
M
Melissa L
3 contributionsDidn't like
• 3/29/26Pizza crust was burnt on the bottom. The pizza was $36 and barely had any toppings on it.
L
Laura C
8 contributionsDidn't like
• 7/17/26The pizza is tasteless. Worst pizza I've even had. It's like tomato sauce brushed on floppy crust with basically no cheese at all. I'm talking about you literally can't find the cheese. There's so many amazing pizza places around Cincinnati, there's no point in wasting time or money on something this bad.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store