I ordered the Sicilian pizza again from here. That's because it was so good the first time I tried it.
Many decades ago there was a pizza place in the Edgewood shopping center called Frank's Pizza. They had hands down the best round pizza and Sicilian pizza anywhere. They went out of business and I have seen hardly any pizza places that offer the Sicilian until I discovered Italian Sensation. The crust is perfect, the sauce is delicious, and plenty of cheese, it's just a really really good Sicilian pizza.
For those of you that may think that this is similar to a deep dish pizza, it is not.
Next time you are thinking about ordering a deep dish pizza from one of the garbage Pizza chain restaurants that promote them, skip it and get the Sicilian pizza here.
K
Kym M
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/14/24
• DoorDash review
The chicken panini was delicious. The Fettuccine Alfredo was a little bland in flavor. And the mozzarella sticks were a tad disappointing, a bit stiff and not not quite "melted" on the inside, maybe they were overdone.
I know times are tough, and prices are high everywhere, so when splurging for delivery on a Friday night, I definitely didn't get my money's worth having paid almost $60!
J
Jessica P
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/27/25
• DoorDash order
This was sad. Paid over $80 and it was bland and lacking. The Pasta Caprese was just tomato sauce and pasta, and only has Mozz because we paid extra for it. The Fettuccine Alfredo is more than pathetic with unseasoned chicken and next to no sauce. Side Broccoli was undercooked and wet? Bruschetta was acceptable but for the price - definitely not. You will get better food if you make it at home. I've never left a review before, but this was just "wtf?"
I paid $18 for one serving of spaghetti and canned tomato sauce.
S
Susan M
Emerging Expert • 41 contributions
Liked
• 5/29/24
• DoorDash order
The salad is nice. The shrimp are a bit too dark for my taste, but good. All is good, but a bit pricey for the shrimp
M
Michael K
9 contributions
Liked
• 5/13/23
• DoorDash order
I very much enjoy Italian sensation. My overall review of four stars is not for the pizza, which is usually five stars. I'm just giving it an overall rating for all food that I have tried. pretty much everything I have tried here has been good but I will never order the fried mushrooms again and I don't recommend anyone does. 95% breading and mushrooms the size of large peas. I would like to see them change their recipe for that item and actually use some normal sized mushrooms.
the pizza is one of only two or three places I will order in my area. if you patronize Domino's, Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, or Papa John's, you have poor taste in pizza. support your local businesses and get some good pizza if you patronize the aforementioned.
