Main Street Pizza is The Absolute Best that I have had in Westchester. I am kinda Picky about My Pizza. The Grandma is Excellent and Somehow they Consistently make the Pizza exactly as I Specified. The Crust is Thin, Tasty and Crisp. You can always add their toppibgs or Your own toppings. The Pizza never fails Fresh or Re-heated. Highly Highly Recommend.
J
JOSH P
4 contributions
Loved
• 10/29/25
• DoorDash order
I thought it was great guys, really. Solid NY pie with the toppings prepared and portioned how I like it. Crust was just crisp enough. For me this is the best spot in Tarrytown.
A
Amy L
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Loved
• 10/5/25
• DoorDash order
I asked for a special order - it was for a patient at the nursing home, they just wanted a cheese sandwich, but other wanted pasta, so I didn't want to order from multiple places, Main St pizza hit it out of the park, they made EXACTLY what I requested. We'll be ordering from them again next week
Barbara S
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/14/26
• DoorDash order
Homemade Lasagna was just all right;
hated the broccolini - not what I expected.
Zeppole Balls are small and the powdered sugar was not white so i'm letting someone else try them first.
Tiramisu was tasty.
Doubt I will be ordering again.
P
Pete D
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/22/24
• DoorDash order
Middle of the road, not complaining but not recommended. little salty and questions if 100% mozzarella. I added broccoli Rabe to Cheese Calzone with ricotta and extra cheese..ricotta non existent. plus not cooked enough. Sicilian Pizza Slice was perfect crust and reg Cheese Pizza Slice just missed
