I must say, Nick's Sandwich Shop exceeded my expectations! The sandwich I had was absolutely delicious, fresh meat and packed with flavor. I tried the #1 (ham, salami, and provolone), and wow, I was beyond pleased.
I also had the empanadas and tried the beef, which was incredibly tasty. And now, I’m enjoying the sausage, it’s just as good! I’m so happy TikTok led me here because everything has been fantastic. The sandwiches are fresh, the food is delicious, and the staff is so kind and welcoming.
My daughter loved it as well and can’t stop talking about how good the food is. Her words: “It’s super good!”
Thank you, Nick's Sandwich Shop—I can’t wait to come back!
C
Carlos M
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/2/23
• DoorDash order
I added banna peppers to my BLT and it was the best . The BLT alone is fresh and the bread soft. The bacon crispy. You need to come here if you want a real sandwhich! Their chicken cutlets are to die for !
J
Judith S
2 contributions
Liked
• 1/14/26
• DoorDash order
Sandwich was fresh and tasty. Chicken perfectly seasoned. I had the brownie. It was amazing. Worth every calorie.
T
Tom N
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/2/26
• DoorDash order
While the food tastes good, most other sandwich shop that I've ordered from provide more substantial sandwiches for money spent. Also, the advertising for the empanada is deceiving. The item is lised as plural, the photo shows eight Empanadas and shows two containers of dipping sauce. The wording and photo leads one to believe that the order will include more than one empanada. I was fooled and only received the one empanada and not Empanadas. The owners of this food place should clearly state that there is only one included for the price and photo shown. I will not order from this place ever again.
M
mike s
1 contributions
Liked
• 6/8/26
• DoorDash order
Nicks sandwich shop has sky rocketed imo since the change of ownership. The new owners present various different cultures in their food and that has to be my favorite part. From Latin American inspired sandwiches to Argentinian empanadas and of course your original Italian sandwiches. They're killing it! Best sandwich shop in north jersey. Always consistent always fresh always delicious! Thank you Carlos and family for your dedication and love
