Honestly this is the best pizza I've ever had! We got the Original Margherita the crust is perfectly cooked and the flavor is perfection! The sauce to cheese ratio.... sensational! I mean they understood the assignment!!! We will definitely be back!
J
Jon M
5 contributions
Loved
• 6/9/26
• DoorDash order
10/10 I had been feeling under the weather all day and couldn't eat and when I finally got my appetite back I needed a little comfort food that would be easy on my belly and help me sleep like a baby. When I tell you the heft of the bag as it was handed to me was my first green flag. It was perfect temp when it arrived. I am not exaggerating when I tell you the plastic to go knife sliced through the chicken cutlet like butter. The pasta perfectly cooked. The sauce beautiful fresh and abundant. This dish came in clutch and I am confidant that this is Nona approved.
J
Jamee B
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/20/25
• DoorDash order
Absolutely phenomenal! Their penne vodka is the best I've ever had. They include a piece of bread on the side, which is the same as they use for their pizzas and it's the BEST. I usually ask for extra and they really hook me up. Their Cheese Calzone is awesome too! It's my favorite Italian place in the area and we order from them all the time, their food is always hot and fresh and everything we've ever tried has been absolutely incredible.
N
Nick N
2 contributions
Loved
• 7/20/25
• DoorDash order
The most authentic neapolian style pizza I've had in the U.S. so far. The Diavola brings me right back to Italy, and the rustic bread is just about the best you can find around here. Little pricey, sure, but the quality is superb! Highly recommend this spot!
M
Mitsuko H
1 contributions
Loved
• 3/17/26
• DoorDash order
The food was good but arrived cold (pizza, meatballs, salad). The Door Dasher stopped along the way. The restaurant was only 6 mins away, and stop was short. The order seemed ready, but then there was an additional delay at the restaurant. However, we ordered close to 9pm and we were grateful Original Flavor 1889 stays open until 10pm on a Monday. We reheated the food and it was good! The AMERICANA pizza has a good crust and excellent flavor, with a nice amount of pepperoni. The pepperoni is a little fancier salami, but tastes like you'd expect pepperoni to taste. The Polpette al Sugo (meatballs) were good and come with pizza dough baked as bread, which was very good. The Misticanza Salad is a nice salad. I easily removed the red onion (it's a surcharge of $2 for the restaurant to hold the onion). The dressing could use more vinegar. Also, you need to ask for red pepper flakes (and parm) if you want for your pizza. Overall, I recommend, but consider dine-in or pickup.
