I love the Create Your Own Pizza : 14" garlic stuffed with everything (pineapple, anchovies, Philly steak, mushroom, spinach, onion, black olives, Parmigiano, & don't forget the chicken for more meat, ranch, well done, clean cut), delicious! Needs a thicker crust option. The original was maybe a 16th an inch thick. Too weak, & not as filling, making you reach for more. Double the thickness, please! Nice Double Chocolate Chip Brownie . Soft. Maybe add some bread sticks for filler? Full hits your hard @ ~5 slices. Would be nice to fault at 3 instead of downing half a pizza mostly made of toppings. Expensive. Got 3 of these & the Brownie for 200+tip. Double the crust thickness would have made it more worth it, but the well-done option is crucial for allergies. Have a good one, all!
M
Melina D
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/28/26
• DoorDash order
This genuinely was the best pizza and garlic bread I've ever had. This was so fresh, I mean the pepperoni and spicy Italian sausage was absolutely chefs kiss. Who ever made this pizza and garlic bread deserves to be kissed by God himself. I hope a ridiculously rich sugar daddy/mommy comes into your life and bless you tremendously. As a college student, I don't get served pizza like this at my dining hall, so being able to have had this pizza was life changing. I'm still looking back at this photo, a few days after ordering and missing it like a desperate ex. I will definitely be ordering this again. This pizza has changed me in the best way possible. Thank you Papa John's....Thank you.
J
Jennica M
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Loved
• 9/25/23
• DoorDash order
It would be nice if they included 2 sauce packets in an XL, and the option not to get a pepper as a garnish. Otherwise, best place. They have well-done baking, low nightshade sauce, and excellent pizza. Love the anchovies!
N
Noelani B
1 contributions
Loved
• 2/14/26
• DoorDash order
Five stars ts was literally the most equivocally bussing and saucy pizza I've ever had in my life. Plus I hate crust and I straight devoured the whole slice dude, 10/10, would roll up and shove my face here again. It was hella warm still when I pulled up and I was like 15 late I can't lie, and the small pizza was perfect for one person, so it was so gas, it was also ready incredibly fast so that was fire. Hell yeah
M
Maylani B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/14/22
• DoorDash order
Toppings slip and slide off the slice with little crust to hold it and there's little sauce in between. There's plenty of breadsticks that are pretty good but what is one to do with ten breadsticks and half of a little tiny cuplet of sauce? Is it a complementary sample and the marinara sauce is to be ordered separately? I suppose I could slide the pizza toppings onto the breadsticks and just be quiet.
