How you doin’! Papa Luigi’s has been a Cudahy landmark for close to four decades. Since 1982, Sal and his family have grown to be one of Milwaukee’s top Italian restaurants by his commitment to qualit…
The crab pasta (I called & substituted angel hair) was so delicious & a great portion. Tiramisu authentic & very good.
D
Daniel R
Local Expert • 85 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/17/24
• DoorDash order
Prices are way to high for regular items. For specialty items like crab linguine, which I love, it's not as bad. But an 8" pizza for $20? That's insane. I can get a 16" pizza special with extras for $20 by ordering elsewhere. Not to mention that Sal's Seafood Sensation is a dollar more than the Crab Linguine and simply isn't as good. Tastes like frozen shrimp and frozen tiny scallops. I can barely detect either crab or lobster on that dish. It should be $5 cheaper than crab linguine.
J
Jennifer B
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/17/25
• DoorDash review
This pizza was terrible and I was charged even more for odering from DoorDash and the pizza was chewy and the garlic bred was salty vs garlicky and buttery. I should have just put a frozen tombstone in the oven and it would have been better.
T
Todd H
17 contributions
Loved
• 5/20/23
• DoorDash order
had a 16 inch sausage black and green olives mushrooms and onion . wow it was loaded up and fantastic . my go to place for pizza yum yum .
D
Daniel R
Local Expert • 85 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/20/25
• DoorDash order
While I appreciate real crab in Crab Linguini, the prices have gone up so significantly, while the quality has reduced with the same proportion. The sauce was broken, which means an oily grainy mess. I'll order this exactly one more time.
