The brothers Isihos were born in Greece and immigrated to the United States in 1972. Mike and Louie opened the Pegasus I Restaurant in Malaga, New Jersey, in 1985. They joined forces in 1993 and opene…
Pegasus always gives you quality meals as their priority and this Eggplant Parmigiana with a Side of Pasta is no exception. It was delivered hot and enough for 2 meals. The chicken pasta soup was yummy too. I highly recommend Pegasus Diner!!
B
Bre D
1 contributions
Loved
• 2/27/26
• DoorDash order
I definitely recommend the seafood supreme. The chef made it exactly as I ordered it. The flavors and everything about this dish is exceptional. They went above and beyond I would give them 1 million stars Pegasus rules this was perfect.
T
Theresa M
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Loved
• 7/21/24
• DoorDash order
Delicious Lasagna, large portion size!
H
Heidi B
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/11/25
• DoorDash order
Didn't seemed cooked all the way. Bread was hard and just tossed into the bag.
M
Mike M
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/17/25
• DoorDash order
We order breakfast from Pegasus the pancakes were good thank god, but not all of the order was good. The cream chip beef was burnt it looked fine when unpacking it from the bag but soon as I opened the container that the chipped beef was packed in you could smell that it burnt and it taste burnt even worse! It's disappointing, especially if we could smell it as soon I opened the cream chip beef it smelled burnt bad it was not good. They had to know it was burnt when the cook packed it up to send out snd they packed it up and sent it out for us to eat anyway. That really disappointing that they would do that, especially because food is so expense.
I wasn't sure if you can or could return food ordered on the DoorDash app, it was the first time DoorDashing ever. We truly like Pegasus food but that was a total disappointed and disaster. We also order breakfast meat sides bacon and sausage. They sent us bacon and scrapple we just eat anyway. Never again!!!
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Appetizers
Salads
Served with Bread & Butter. Little Extra on Top for an additional charge
Homemade Soups
Served with Crackers, Bread and Butter
Pegasus Burgers
½ lb Black Angus Burgers, Cooked to your Preferred Temperature, Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
“It’s Greek to Me”
Your Choice. Wrapped in Toasted Pita Bread Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
Cold Sandwiches
Your Choice. On Your Choice of Bread with Lettuce & Tomato Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
Subs
Your Choice. Tomato, Onions and our Secret Sub Dressing Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
Paninis
Your Choice. Served with French Fries & a Pickle, Add Coleslaw for an additional cost.
Wraps
Your Choice. Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
Clubs
Your Choice. On Your Choice of Toast with Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo. Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
Specialty Sandwiches
Served with French Fries, Pickle & Coleslaw for additional cost.
Pastas
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter. Upgrade to Caesar Salad or Greek Salad for an additional cost. Pasta Extras for an additional costs.
Chicken
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter. Upgrade to Caesar Salad or Greek Salad for an additional cost. Served with Two Vegetables or a Side of Pasta.
Veal
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter. Upgrade to Caesar Salad or Greek Salad for an additional cost. Served with Two Vegetables or a Side of Pasta.
Meat Specialties
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter. Upgrade to Caesar Salad or Greek Salad for an additional cost. Served with Two Vegetables or a Side of Pasta.
Dinner Classics
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter. Upgrade to Caesar Salad or Greek Salad for an additional cost. Served with Two Vegetables or a Side of Pasta.
Authentic Greek Dishes
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter
Gluten Free
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad
Broiled Selection
Served with Drawn Butter, Tartar & Cocktail Sauce.
Fried Selection
Served with Cocktail & Tartar Sauce.
Seafood Scampi’s
Served with Soup Du Jour or House Salad, Bread and Butter. Upgrade to Caesar Salad or Greek Salad for an additional cost.
Potato Bar
Sides
Farm Fresh Eggs - Breakfast Favorites
Served all day. Any Style with Home Fries or Country Style Potatoes, Toast & Jelly. Substitute Fruit Cup Instead of Home Fries for an additional cost. Add Extra Egg, Cheese or Egg Whites for an additional cost.
Omelet Selection
Served with Home Fries or Country Style Potatoes, Toast & Jelly. Substitute Fruit Cup Instead of Home Fries for an additional cost. Add Extra Egg, Cheese or Egg Whites for an additional cost.
Breakfast Extras
From the Griddle
Served with butter and syrup.
Children’s Menu
Your choice. For Children 12 & Under.
From the Griddle
Served with Butter & Syrup. Add Fruit Toppings (Cherry, Apple, Blueberry, Peach, Strawberry, or Nutella) for an additional charge.
