The Char-Grilled Hot Wings are so consistently good each time! After I eat the last one I'm already thinking okay when are we ordering them again. Chipotle Chicken Pie was an awesome pairing as well, ingredients were perfectly placed!
M
Melanie C
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/4/25
• DoorDash order
Char-Grilled Hot Wings: The wings were actually burned, not just charred skin; the kind of burned that is bitter, acidic, and taints the flavor of the remaining meat. Cannot recommend.
The Sm. Steak & Mushroom Pie: the steak was tough and chewy like jerky, which was unexpected and not desired. Cannot recommend.
M
Mary S
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Loved
• 9/24/25
• DoorDash order
The Steak & Mushroom Pie was delicious! The marinated steak was done to perfection. I especially enjoyed the roasted garlic.
K
Karen N
Local Expert • 184 contributions
Loved
• 6/27/22
• DoorDash order
best pizza I have had in years! perfectly cooked zero grease. the salad was fresh and Everything was perfect!
H
Heather M
5 contributions
Liked
• 11/19/24
• DoorDash order
I love P&P when I am visiting Montgomery- their pizza never disappoints. This time I also tried the Char-Grilled Hot Wings which were a little burnt and had the texture of beef jerky. The Gorgonzola cheese that came with it was incredible though
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
*Seasonal Menu!*
A rotating feature menu highlighting fresh, seasonal ingredients and limited-time creations. Selections change regularly based on availability and seasonal flavors.
Starters
Greens
Perfect to share or large enough to make a meal, our salads are made with the freshest ingredients. All of our dressings and even the focaccia bread for our croutons are made in-house. (small serves one–two/large serves two–three).
Sandwiches
Baked on ciabatta bread and served with kettle chips.
Small House & Specialty Pies
10" Pies (GF: 12"x12" square) - All of our specialty pies begin with a blend of provolone & mozzarella on our house-made, hand-tossed dough. The crust is finished with roasted garlic oil & a pinch of salt.
(Select your preferred crust option during customization.)
Large House & Specialty Pies
16" Pies - All of our pies begin with a blend of provolone & mozzarella on our house-made, hand-tossed dough. The crust is finished with roasted garlic oil & a pinch of salt.
**Half & Half Specialty Pies are not available for third-party services**
