Pizza Pete is named after my father, Peter Einwiller, a Vietnam War veteran and one of the grateful dead's largest supporters. In Cudahy, he was known for his enormous heart, tie-dyes, and wearing sho…
The Hand Tossed (12") pizza was not bad. I did not alter anything. If I order again, I'll order extra cheese and extra pepperoni. They have the pepperonis that curl up. The Chef Salad had a lot of meat which is great. I needed more lettuce. The chicken was meh, but all my sauces came separate and it had no taste. Perhaps because the way they were ordered. Overall, I'd give them another try.
N
Nicole and Mark L
9 contributions
Liked
• 3/7/26
• DoorDash order
Excellent Pizza first time ordering we will be back great tasting great flavor. I must try. A++++++ Large pizza for the price completely fresh tasting came hot
R
RICHARD G
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/17/26
• DoorDash review
Today I had the worst pizza I have had from a restaurant in years… and that pizza came from Pizza Pete’s. I ordered a thin crust sausage pizza with extra sausage and I received a hand tossed pizza without the extra sausage. I ordered plain (non-breaded) boneless wings and they made breaded. The pizza was so greasy on top that it pooled and we had to take paper towels to soak up the grease. We also ordered a Caesar salad that came with soft/soggy broken up pieces of rye bread as the croutons. They recently changed out their management for whatever reason which I think was a big mistake because there was quality control and commitment to quality food. They have been fantastic for years and now the quality has completely crashed. My recommendation is to stay away. Don’t let this place ruin your love for pizza. Check out the photos attached.
p.s. to top off the terrible experience, their order form allowed you to order a 2-L of Diet Coke… they delivered Diet Pepsi. lol 😳
J
Joe F
10 contributions
Loved
• 11/2/25
• DoorDash order
I've never tried this place before but I was pleased with everything the cheesy garlic bread was great and the pizza was tasty as well.
A
Alyssa M
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/1/25
• DoorDash order
The food was great. However, I dont like how they left one worker to do all the cooking especially on a holiday like New Years Eve. She deserves an incentive or raise!!!
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Appetizers
All appetizers come with a choice of sauce: hot, mild, BBQ, garlic parm, honey mustard, honey sriracha, teriyaki, blue cheese, marinara. Additional sauce for an additional price.
