This place is a rip off. There is barely any meat in the sandwich. It tastes pretty good but not worth the money if I only get a couple of slices of meat in my sandwhich.Everything was fresh and tasted pretty good but I was so disappointed that I will never order from pot belly again. 2.5 stars.
Italian
on another note the Chocolate Brownie Cookie was one of the best cookies ive ever had. They make better cookies than they do sandwiches.
D
Dillon F
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/19/25
• DoorDash order
Usually the sandwiches had plenty of meat and the toppings. Now every sandwich is like a skinny and has nothing on it. One slice of pepperoni on an Italian is wild. Turkey avocado had less meat than a vegan eats. Food used to be good, now is sadly not worth the price.
C
Christopher T
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/7/26
• DoorDash review
Truly a trash restaurant. Horrible quality, miniscule portions, and worse prices. Paid $13 for an "Italian" sandwich that proved to be about 7 inches of stale bread with a few meager slices of salami, no veggies (which I had ordered) and no condiments or sauces (which, again, I had ordered).
For $13 dollars.
Again, 7 inches of stale bread filled dry with 1/10 inch of leftover salami, and nothing else.
I will never order from this restaurant again, and neither should anyone else.
AVOID AT ALL COSTS!
Go instead to Ike's or Firehouse or Jersey Mike's, or hell, even Subway. Anyone, ANYONE but Potbelly.
M
Meagan G
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/21/26
• DoorDash order
The chicken salad sandwich was horrible. The chicken was grizzly and the bread was soggy. I always order this every time but this time it was nasty. I would not order it again from this specific Potbelly's.
S
Susan A
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/10/23
• DoorDash order
I think their bread recipe came straight from the heavens! Best rolls I've ever had! They managed the art of their sandwiches being just as delicious fresh to having it hours later which is great because of how big the portions are.
When I'm really sick, it's the ultimate comfort food
