Pizza was good but had to come back 3 times before it was ready for pick up. Ordered at 3:45pm picked up at 5:30pm .
X
Xavier H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 5 days ago
• DoorDash review
Way too overrated. I was born and raised in New Haven... the only reason people think this is the best is that they are told it is the best, it's unremarkable. Also this place is over priced and always super busy because it's a tourist trap. NY style is better, bring back the dollar slice
I
Isaac L
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/12/26
• DoorDash order
Visiting from out of town. Heard New Haven pizza was really special, and this was the best place for it. Avoided the long wait in person and used DoorDash. I had the SM Calabrian Stinger and the Foxon Park Root Beer. For real, this is a whole distinctive pizza on par with Chicago and New York. I'm a convert!
E
Edward L
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/19/26
• DoorDash order
NYC pizza is far superior...I've heard this touted as the best pizza on earth but it was honestly meh. Very overrated suburban pizza
A
Ann W
5 contributions
Liked
• 7/23/26
• DoorDash order
The pizza is made to perfection. The problem is it's so spicy you can barely enjoy it. I thought it would be hot but not this hot. Otherwise I'd order it again minus those peppers whewww!
