Shelly Pie
4.4(5k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info•
DashPass
Temporarily closed
4.4(5k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Shelly Farren, Mike Aiello, and Jim Holland, longtime friends, decided to launch Shelly Pie on the spur of the moment.
The three of them make up the ownership that gives Shelly Pie its distinct style!…
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Large (12 cut)
$18.15
•81% (103)
#2 Most liked
Medium (8 cut)
$15.95
•84% (105)
#1 Most liked
Small (6 cut)
$13.75
•88% (53)
*GLUTEN FREE* Pizza
$14.29
Sicilian Large
$22.82
•75% (16)
Italian Hoagie
$9.75+
•88% (18)
Reviews5k+ ratings • 100+ public reviews
4.4
of 5 stars
A
Ashley P
1 contributionsLoved
• 12/26/23Shlly is Pie is always a win! The pizza is cheesy and thecl crust is soft and chewy and delicious! The wings are flavorful and oh so good! I highly suggest their ranch and garlic dip/sauce. It's extra but it's delicious on wings, pizza, chicken tenders, everything!
K
Kate N
2 contributionsLoved
• 1/9/26We had been hearing about this pizza place and finally decided to try it. The price seemed a little steep until it arrived. Their servings are HUGE. Think twice the size you expect and twice as much of the toppings. The bite sized Cinnamon Sugar Knots are the size of a big apple, try 8 bites. We cut the Medium (8 cut) pizza into 16, making it about like a normal slice. and yes, it's really good.
J
JAMAYA F
8 contributionsLoved
• 1/6/26Hot, delicious, cheesy and loaded with pepperoni that cooked at the perfect temperature so that the pepperoni doesn't scorch, the cheese bubbles and lightly browns and dough is thin and crispy. Huge size and definitely worth every penny.
D
Deborah S
Emerging Expert • 14 contributionsLoved
• 8/24/25I am in shock! I never had a tuna melt before but it is my new fave sandwich! It was fresh and still warm and the flavor is savory, never expected that! The Cole slaw was the best I have had since I have been ordering thru DoorDash! The slaw was cold and was NOT dry as I have found many others I ordered from other places! I am very pleased with my order, it was scrumptious, thank you!
G
Gretchen L
23 contributionsLoved
• 6/17/25I ordered the medium 8-cut pie. It was the biggest medium pizza I have ever gotten, and it was delicious!!! Definitely worth the money. The pizza was LOADED with fresh mushrooms , pepperoni and black olives. I will definitely get this again.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store