Slice of Brooklyn brings the unique flavors of Brooklyn to Central Jersey!
Our woodfired oven cooks up the best pizzas around, including our famous Old Fashioned Brooklyn pie! Sicilians, rounds, pers…
I ordered the chicken and meatball Parmagiana Subs* to share half and half with someone else. very good tasting meatballs and chicken. Each time it was a lot of chicken. Tastes like my mom's homemade chicken parm and meatballs. I got the same thing twice now. Consistent and filling.
J
Jessie R
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/30/25
• DoorDash order
Almost everything was undercooked. Flavors were okay. Portions were good size. Wings were big and tender (but undercooked inside). Rice balls were tasty but so small for the price (and underdone). Sloppy Joey Panini* and fries would order again.
M
Mari A
15 contributions
Liked
• 7/13/26
• DoorDash order
first time ordering from here and the Wood Fired Wings with the lemon pepper sauce was delicious we loved it! Great size too. Cheesesteak Eggroll was okay but the Napolitano (Cheese Pizza) was delicious too would order from here again.
A
Amy M
4 contributions
Loved
• 7/11/24
• DoorDash order
Big Ben combined the best of both worlds with this one! Can't decide between traditional and Sicilian? You don't have to! The crust was crunchy and pillowy. Fresh basil. Crispy small pepperoni. Great sauce. Highly recommend!!
J
Joy R
2 contributions
Liked
• 2/4/26
• DoorDash order
Normally I love their stuff, the only reason I give it less than 5 stars is their silician was much dryer and a bit more burnt than I'd like. Portion size of the salad was generous given it was $20. All was fresh. I'll be ordering again in the future but maybe trying something new. We were so pleased when we ordered a few times over the summer so it's a bummer it wasn't as good as it was then but hopefully they redeem themselves at our next go around!
