Loved the Ohio Double (YOU BUILD IT!) burgers and especially loved the tallow pretzel nuggets, if the tallow pretzel bites ever come back to door dash we will be sure to order them again!!! We have been checking regularly hoping to catch their return, probably the best soft pretzel side we've found in town so far! Still can't go wrong with the burger and fries but we think about those pretzels often lol
M
Molly P
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 11/14/24
• DoorDash order
They packed the Regular Creamy Mac & Cheese spilling over if you may. Im not mad I was so thrilled. This place is always so good so are the Shack Double (YOU BUILD IT!)* And the chimney sauce was so good. I highly recommend.
S
Samuel M
1 contributions
Loved
• 10/25/25
• DoorDash order
Smash shack is the best burger spot In all of Columbus. If you like a nice thin patty with crispy edges, and a sauce that's similar to in n outs sauce, only better, look no further. All locally sourced Angus beef. The portions are very fairly priced. This is my go to burger spot everytime. Their hotdog is also split and charred, if you know, you know.
N
Nancy P
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Liked
• 6/16/26
• DoorDash order
Would give Smash Shack Burger a ☆3.5☆ stars over all. The Ohio Double (YOU BUILD IT!) burger looked good. My Ohio Single (YOU BUILD IT!) burger tasted pretty good as well after I tweaked it with some Lettuce, Tomato, and Atomic Pickle slices that I had at home, I just don't believe that you should be charged for the basics: Lettuce,Tomato,Pickle,Onion OR condiments for that matter. Especially not .50+ each topping. This isn't Pizza. 🫤 Regular Onion Rings were over cooked, but still tasted ok-ish. The Large Tallow Fry were very tasty! We really liked them. Just remember they are cooked in Beef Tallow; so for vegans, meat dietary restrictions, etc may want to avoid them if this is an issue. In all honesty without the 30% off (Up to $10 only) I don't know that I would order again due to the price and pictures of some other's reviews that looked bad. It's a decent burger, but not an OMG burger. If Smash Shack Burger keeps the discount I would probably be more apt to order again sometime.
A
Annette O
2 contributions
Liked
• 3/25/26
• DoorDash order
the Ohio Double (YOU BUILD IT!) was very good and nice and big, the bun was absolutely fantastic. honestly top tier burger. the Regular Tallow Fry were good but I was disappointed because with somefresh cut fries this becomes a no question first choice ifI want a burger and fries. I will be ordering from here again.
