THE BEST PIZZA IN SAN DIEGO. We live in Little Italy and im realllly picky about pizza and we have access to some of the best pizza in Little Italy but truthfully, Sextons pizza outshines any pizza I've had in all of San Diego. They are consistent and affordable. They have quality ingredients. The crust and dough are absolutely delicious and the succulent pepperoni and suace are SO FLAVORFUL. I love it sm that I kinda wish they did like a chicken bacon ranch pizza but I don't mind that they specialize either, I think it's classy......Sextons WE LOVEEEE YOU!!! Please never sell out like all the other restaurants in San Diego and continue to keep your quality and consistency where it's at now. You have loyal customers in us!
N
Nella N
1 contribuciones
Loved
• 6 days ago
• DoorDash review
Some of the best NYC pizza, reminds of living in the LES and grabbing a nice pie with that right crisp I love! Their Parmesan tater tots thoo fire
C
Cameron H
1 contribuciones
Loved
• 24/2/26
• DoorDash order
This is my new spot in SD. Best pizza in town, in my humble New England opinion...
Crust has some chew, is seasoned perfectly. No slop on arrival which was crazy for a doordashed 16 inch thin pie. They ACTUALLY USED THE STEAM PORTS. Order this pizza. I'm reviewing it because I got it last week and I'm back here to order again.
8.1 delivery slice, I'd bet it's a 9.1 right out the door. To give you an idea of how well it seems to travel.
C
Cameron M
1 contribuciones
Loved
• 8/11/25
• DoorDash order
A new favorite in San Diego! Tastes amazing, you can really tell they care about high quality fresh ingredients. A good deal with generous portion sizes. Don't forget the ranch, it is top notch! I will absolutely be ordering again.
E
Eduardo S
1 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 4 days ago
• DoorDash order
Ordered this bc one of their employees brought some pizza to my job and it was AMAZING, today's pizza that I paid $30 for was kinda disappointing. Soggy and burnt. For the price I feel like the quality could be a lot better.
