Nachos Al Fuego is unique and perfectly balanced nacho joy. It's a must-try. Excellent pizza- my go to DIY is the prosciutto, mushroom, and arugula with classic house sauce. My husband loves the Meatball Sub, and the fries are crispy and delicious spirals. The kid's Mac N' Cheese is really nice, with a spot on béchamel sauce like Mom used to make on cavatappi noodles. The churros get an honorable mention. They're amazing when done properly- sometimes they forget the filling or overdo it, but still very nice. Wow when they get it just so. They use very nice take out boxes, fyi, so everything should hold up nicely (even the churros which they strangely insist on packing with fresh cut berries up against the crisp- unpack that first to stop the sog).
A
Annie F
1 contribuciones
Liked
• 16/4/26
• DoorDash order
The Veggie Pita was a lot of food. I had enough for lunch the next day. Everything was fresh. The Caesar Salad dressing is the what I'm looking for when I crave a Caesar. Yum! The Chicken Milanese had perfect cutlets. No negative comments to add.
E
Elizabeth O
2 contribuciones
Loved
• 17/8/25
• DoorDash review
This was our third time eating from Fire on Fifth. And it will not be our last! We've tried the Firebird, meatball sub, and Chicken Milanese sandwiches, the wings, Kitchen Sink salad, and finally last night, pizzas! The photo is of a build your own on the house crust. Holy explosion of deliciousness! It was exactly how I hoped it would taste, plus a lot better. My husband also built his own using the cracker crust. To die for!The ingredients are super fresh and plentiful. Even for traveling a half hour for delivery, the quality is fantastic. Great portion sizes and the prices are definitely fair. I can't imagine trying it fresh in restaurant. I would probably pass out from goodness overload. Highly recommend! Can't wait for leftovers today!
A
Allysa H
Experto local • 51 contribuciones
Loved
• 2/7/23
• DoorDash order
I am in such bliss right now being able to get this delivered! I ordered a Margherita pizza, it is thin crust and it's the best around because it is a wood fire pizza stone oven! I also enjoyed the Cheese Curds. They come with parm blend and they are definitely home made! I decided to try the Jumbo Pretzel. I enjoy the creamy beer cheese sauce it comes with but I am not a big fan of the homemade honey Dijon mustard?
Overall, I will be ordering a lot! Or visiting in person if I can! Thank you!!!!
M
Michelle S
1 contribuciones
Liked
• 31/5/26
• DoorDash order
Everything was delicious but the chips and salsa was disappointing . We received like 8 chips and they hardly put any salsa in the container.
