Been a customer since 2005
Love the Pizza and best sauce.
Johnny whoever is cutting the pie smack them so they cut it right.
T
Tom H
2 contribuciones
Liked
• 31/12/25
• Orden de DoorDash
Pizzas had a decent amount of toppings on them. One pizza was the white spinach pie and the other pie was half bacon and half pepperoni. Both were nice and cheesy. Meatball parm sub. There were five tender meatballs on the sub was really good with lots of cheese. Wings were nice and plump. But needed more hot sauce.Onion rings were large and crispy and gave you a good amount of them.
A
Anne B
1 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 24/4/26
• Calificación de DoorDash
I used to love picnic pizza but I feel the quality has gone downhill. I don't usually write reviews but I wanted to share my recent experience. The boneless wing were small dry chicken "tater tot"-sized pieces. The antipasto salad seemed to be made with the same cheap deli meats as the cold subs. The pickled carrot tasted bad or old. The Caesar salad had cheap "shaker" cheese. The pizza crust was good but not like it used to be (used to have a woodfired style) It tasted good after a long day but the price and quality were not good. $50 for a small 12" pizza, two salads and a small order of "boneless wings". I am sad to say that times have changed and I don't think I would order again unless they improve the quality. I was previously a huge picnic fan! Please bring back the quality! For reference, for a fresh, special pizza, I like Apizza in New Paltz for a good pizza and salad. For an affordable weeknight daily driver pizza I like Village Pizza in Shokan. Thank you for reading.
J
Jennifer R
2 contribuciones
Loved
• 24/9/25
• Orden de DoorDash
I originally ordered this pizza because a friend of mine posted it on his Instagram and it looked so yummy that I asked what it was and where he obtained it. My hair stylist also had told me that this place is her family's favorite.
This is my 2nd time ordering it. It's the tastiest white pizza I've ever had. Just enough garlic with not too crunchy or too soggy broccoli. And loads of ricotta! Just the smell. For a medium it's huge and lasts me many days for dinner. I definitely recommend ordering this ASAP!!
M
Maria M
Nuevo experto • 10 contribuciones
Liked
• 13/5/26
• Orden de DoorDash
best tuna salad evever from here. and enough for several people. ordered a large tuna salad and it was better then previous ones oordered.$ 17.00 for the ..large. about time it wasmade right
