Oddfellows Ice Cream Menu
$$Sweets, Dessert, Ice Cream
Get delivery or pickup from Oddfellows Ice Cream when you order online with DoorDash
Oddfellows Ice Cream Menu
Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest storeCategories
- Party Packs
- Classic Flavors
- OddFellows Favorites
- Vegan Flavors
- Sandwiches
- Beverages
Party Packs
3 To-Go Tub Pack
Save $4.50 when you purchase this 3 pack of to-go tubs. Choose 3 flavors and have a little party at home.
$30 +
6 To-Go Tub Pack
Save $9.00 when you party! Perfect for parties! Choose six to-go tubs of our unique ice cream flavors in a convenient to-go pack.
$60 +
DIY Sundae Pack
Have an ice cream sundae party at home! Choose 4 ice cream to-go tubs and 6 toppings and have a make-your-ice cream sundae party at home!
$65 +
Root Beer Float Pack
Create a classic soda float at home. Comes with two glass bottles of Boylan's Root Beer and a to-go tub of Vanilla Bean ice cream. Scoop, sip and float away.
$16 +
New Flavor 3 Pack
We just added three new flavors to our pint collection. Get one tub of each of the following flavors:
Brooklyn Blackout
Cookie Jar
Salted Caramel Toffee
$30 +
Classic Flavors
Sprinkles
Sweet cream ice cream loaded with rainbow sprinkles
Contains dairy, eggs, soy.
$11.5 +
Coffee Crunch
Coffee ice cream with a housemade coffee soil mixed in.
Contains dairy, eggs gluten, almond floiu.
$11.5 +
Chocolate Chunk
Rich chocolate ice cream with morsels of dark chocolate.
Contains dairy, eggs.
$11.5 +
Cookies & Mint
Mint ice cream swirled with crushed chocolate cookies.
Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
$11.5 +
Cookies & Cream
Sweet cream ice cream folded with chocolate cookies.
Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
$11.5 +
Vanilla Bean
Vanilla ice cream made with real Madagascar vanilla bean.
Contains dairy, eggs.
$11.5 +
Strawberry Jam
Strawberry ice cream with swirls of fresh strawberry jam.
Contains dairy, eggs.
$11.5 +
OddFellows Favorites
Cookie Jar
Sweet cream ice cream with crushed Oreo's, chocolate chip cookie dough & rainbow sprinkles.
Contains dairy, egg, gluten.
$11.5 +
Brooklyn Blackout
Chocolate ice cream with brownie chunks & chocolate pudding swirls.
Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten.
$11.5 +
Peanut Butter S'mores
Peanut butter ice cream with marshmallows, chocolate chunks, and graham soil.
Contains dairy, eggs, gluten, gelatin.
$11.5 +
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
Passionfruit ice cream with apricot jam ribbons and chopped pistachios.
Contains dairy, eggs. pistachio.
$11.5 +
Sea Salt Pistachio
Smooth pistachio ice cream with a hint of sea salt
contains: Dairy, eggs, nuts
$11.5 +
Hummingbird
Brown Sugar ice cream with pineapple swirls and housemade coconut cake chunks.
Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten
$11.5 +
Miso Peanut Butter & Jelly
A savory miso ice cream with swirls of sour cherry jam and a housemade Nutter Butter Soil. Contains: dairy, egg, gluten, nuts
$11.5 +
Vegan Flavors
Vegan Chocolate Chunk
Chocolate cashew-based ice cream with chunks of dark chocolate.
Contains cashew, soy
$11.5 +
Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
Coconut milk-based ice cream with mango swirls gobs of mochi rice.
Contains coconut, gluten.
$11.5 +
Vegan Coconut Pandan
Coconut milk based ice cream infused with pandan. Tastes like coconut with a hint of vanilla.
Contains: coconut
$11.5 +
Vegan Grasshopper
Cashew milk based chocolate mint ice cream with crushed Oreo cookies mixed in.
$11.5 +
Exotic Fruits sorbet
Sorbet blend of mango, banana, guava and passionfruit. Vegan and gluten free!
$11.5 +
Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Choose an ice cream flavors for us to squish between two delicious chocolate chip cookies.
$9.5 +
Chocolate Chunk Cookie (No Ice Cream)
A delicious chocolate chunk cookie, perfect for a sweet craving without the ice cream.
$2.5 +
Beverages
Milkshake
16 oz. milkshake made with our home-made ice cream. for details on the milkshake flavors available, please call our chestnut hill scoop shop at 617-505-6446 and write in the flavors in the special instruction box.
$11 +
Bottled Soda
Boylan's Glass Bottled Soda
$4 +
Water Bottle
16.9 fl oz. Plastic Bottled Water.
$2.5 +