Oddfellows Ice Cream Menu
$$Sweets, Dessert, Ice Cream
Get delivery or pickup from Oddfellows Ice Cream when you order online with DoorDash
Oddfellows Ice Cream Menu
Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest storeCategories
- OddFellows Classic Flavors
- OddFellows Specialty Flavors
- Vegan Ice Cream
- Ice Cream Sandwiches
- To-Go Toppings
- Milkshakes
OddFellows Classic Flavors
Coffee Crunch
Our most popular coffee-based, crunchy ice cream! Coffee base with coffee soil almond flour, sugar, salt, coffee, flour, and butter. Contains dairy, eggs, almonds.
$11.5 +
Sprinkles
Sweet cream ice cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. Contains dairy, eggs, and sprinkles.
$11.5 +
Cookies & Mint
Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, and gluten.
$11.5 +
Vanilla Bean
Sweet cream vanilla ice cream base with real Madagascar vanilla beans. Contains dairy and eggs.
$11.5 +
Cookies & Cream
Sweet cream ice cream base with chunks of chocolate cookie. You might be interested to learn that cookies and cream was invented here in new York city. We were surprised to learn that it was invented at all we assumed it evolved from the ooze with us humans. Contains dairy, egg, and gluten.
$11.5 +
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
Saffron Passionfruit ice cream base with candied apricots and pistachios. Contains dairy, egg, pistachio.
$11.5 +
Chocolate Chunk
Dark chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips.
Contains dairy, eggs, coconut.
$11.5 +
Strawberry jam
Strawberry ice cream with swirls of strawberry jam. Contains dairy and eggs.
$11.5 +
Peanut Butter S'mores
PB ice cream with marshmallow, graham soil and chocolate chunks
Contains: dairy, peanuts, gluten, gelatin, eggs
$11.5 +
OddFellows Specialty Flavors
Vanilla Blackberry Blondie
Madagascar Vanilla Bean ice cream with blackberry swirls and chunks of housemade blondies.
$11.5 +
Matcha Strawberry
Matcha green tea ice cream with strawberry swirls.
$11.5 +
Cookie Jar
Sweet cream ice cream with crushed Oreos, chocolate chip cookie dough and rainbow sprinkles.
$11.5 +
Brooklyn Blackout
Chocolate ice cream with housemade chocolate cake and chocolate fudge swirls. CHOCOLATE CHOCOLATE CHOCOLATE
$11.5 +
Vegan Ice Cream
Vegan Grasshopper
Mint chocolate ice cream made from cashew milk with chocolate cookies crumbles
Contains: cashew, wheat
$12 +
Vegan Chocolate Chunk
Vegan Chocolate ice cream made with cashew milk with chocolate chunks mixed in
Contains: cashew, soy
$12 +
Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
Crafted with rich, dairy-free coconut milk, this vegan ice cream is swirled with vibrant mango swirls and studded with chewy rice mochi. Contains: coconut, gluten
$12 +
Vegan Coconut Pandan
A coconut milk based ice cream infused with pandan.
$11.5 +
Ice Cream Sandwiches
DIY Ice Cream Sandwich
Two chewy chocolate chip cookies with your choice of OddFellows ice cream sandwiched inside. Yum!
$8.5 +
To-Go Toppings
Raspberry Sauce
A sweet and tart sauce made from fresh raspberries, typically used to enhance desserts.
$4.5 +
Sour Cherry Sauce
A tangy topping made from sour cherries, typically simmered to enhance flavor and create a smooth texture.
$4.5 +
Rainbow Sprinkles
Typically used as a colorful addition to desserts, enhancing both appearance and texture.
$4 +
Chocolate Sprinkles
Chocolate sprinkles typically used as a topping, adding a sweet and crunchy texture to desserts.
$4 +
Chopped Golden Graham Crackers
Golden graham crackers, finely chopped for a crunchy texture to complement your dessert.
$4 +
Reese's PB Sauce
A smooth peanut butter sauce, incorporating the iconic Reese's flavor, designed to complement your dessert.
$4 +
Milkshakes
DIY Milkshake
Choose your flavor of ice cream and have it blended up with milk for a refreshing milkshake.
$13 +