Potter's Pizza Menu
$$Sandwiches, Pizza, Dessert, Chicken Wings
Get delivery or pickup from Potter's Pizza when you order online with DoorDash
Potter's Pizza Menu
Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest storeCategories
- 10" Small Pizza
- 12" Medium Pizza
- 14" Large Pizza
- Salads
- 16" Extra Large Pizza
- Breads
- Wings
- Pasta
- Hot Sandwiches
- Hot Sandwiches Combo
- Calzone
- Desserts
- Chips
- Sides
- Drinks
10" Small Pizza
10" Build Your Own Pizza
$9.97 +
10" Texan
Bold ingredients with customizable options for crust and sauce. Crust choices include Regular, Thin, Thick, Pan, Cheezy Crust, Crustless (Keto Friendly), and Gluten Free. Sauce options range from classic Marinara to BBQ and Ranch.
$15.08 +
10" Plenty
10" pizza with customizable crusts and various sauce options including marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and more, to suit your taste.
$15.08 +
10" Premier
Small 10" pizza with various crust options, including gluten-free and keto-friendly. Customizable sauce choices like marinara, Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, ranch, buffalo base, taco sauce, and more.
$16.33 +
10" Tropics
Tropical pizza with customizable crust options, including gluten-free and keto-friendly. Variety of sauces like Marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and more.
$14.77 +
10" Garden
Fresh, vibrant vegetables with your choice of crust and sauce, including options like regular, thin, or gluten-free crust, and sauces like marinara, Alfredo, or BBQ.
$15.08 +
10" Texas Heat
Spicy flavors of Texas. Choose from various crust and sauce options, including keto-friendly and gluten-free.
$16.33 +
10" Chicken Alfredo
Regular, thin, thick, pan, cheezy, crustless (keto), or gluten-free. Variety of sauces available.
$15.08 +
10" Spinach Alfredo
Spinach Alfredo pizza with customizable crust options including regular, thin, thick, pan, Cheezy Crust, crustless, gluten-free. Choose from sauces like marinara, Alfredo, garlic herb, and more.
$15.08 +
10" Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo chicken, choice of crusts including gluten-free and keto-friendly options. Varied sauces like marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, ranch, and more.
$15.08 +
12" Medium Pizza
12" Build Your Own Pizza
Make it your way! Build a pizza with any toppings just the way you want it.
$11.22 +
12" Texan
Regular, thin, thick, pan, or cheezy. Pizza sauce options include red sauce, Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, ranch, buffalo, and more.
$18.95 +
12" Plenty
Choice of crust (Regular, Thin, Thick, Pan, Cheezy Crust) with various pizza sauces (Marinara, Alfredo, Garlic Herb, BBQ, Ranch, Buffalo Base, Taco, Mustard Drizzle, Habanero Mango Drizzle).
$18.95 +
12" Premier
12" medium pizza with choice of crust and various sauces including red, Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, ranch, buffalo, taco, mustard, buffalo drizzle, habanero mango drizzle, or no sauce.
$20.2 +
12" Tropics
Tropical flavors on a 12" pizza. Choose from five crust types and an array of sauces including red marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and more.
$17.08 +
12" Garden
12" Garden Pizza - Choice of crust and sauce. Variety of classic and unique sauces like marinara, garlic herb, BBQ, and more.
$18.95 +
12" Texas Heat
Customizable crust and sauce options. Choose from regular, thin, thick, pan, or cheezy crust, with sauces like red, Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, and more.
$20.2 +
12" Chicken Alfredo
Chicken alfredo with customizable crust options such as regular, thin, thick, pan, and cheesy crust; choice of sauces, including alfredo, marinara, garlic herb, and more.
$18.95 +
12" Spinach Alfredo
Creamy spinach paired with Alfredo sauce, customizable crust, and various sauces such as marinara, BBQ, or garlic herb.
$18.95 +
12" Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo chicken with choice of crust and variety of sauces including marinara, alfredo, BBQ, ranch, buffalo, and more.
$18.95 +
14" Large Pizza
14" Build Your Own Pizza
Make it your own! Build a pizza with any toppings just the way you want it.
$13.72 +
14" Texan
Regular to cheezy crust; sauces from marinara, Alfredo, to unique options like mustard drizzle and habanero mango drizzle.
$22.81 +
14" Plenty
Regular, Thin, Thick, Pan, Cheezy Crust. Sauce options: Marinara, Alfredo, Garlic Herb, BBQ, more.
$22.81 +
14" Premier
14" premier pizza. Choose from Regular, Thin, Thick, Pan, or Cheezy Crust. Variety of sauces including Red Sauce, Alfredo, Garlic Herb, BBQ, and more unique drizzles.
$24.06 +
14" Tropics
Tropical flavors with customizable options for crust and sauce including marinara, Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, and more.
$20.63 +
14" Garden
Fresh vegetables on a classic 14" pizza base. Variety of crusts and sauce options including Alfredo, barbecue, and garlic herb. Customizable to your taste.
$22.81 +
14" Texas Heat
Spicy and savory toppings with choice of crust and various sauce options including marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, garlic herb, and more.
$24.06 +
14" Chicken Alfredo
Regular, thin, thick, pan, or cheezy. Sauce options include red marinara, alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, ranch, buffalo, and more.
$22.81 +
14" Spinach Alfredo
Spinach and alfredo on crust of choice. Variety of sauce options including marinara, garlic herb, BBQ, buffalo, and more.
$22.81 +
14" Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo chicken pizza, 14". Choose from a variety of crust options and sauces like marinara, Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, ranch, taco, and more.
$22.81 +
Salads
Classic Chicken Caesar
A timeless favorite, combining the crispness of romaine with the savory flavor of Chicken and Caesar dressing.
$6.69 +
Classic Club
A satisfying combination of ham, bacon, and eggs, making it a perfect choice for any meal.
$6.99 +
Mediterranean
Mediterranean salad with choice of iceberg, romaine, spinach, or toppings only. Available in small or large. Selection of dressings including ranch, Italian, balsamic, raspberry vinaigrette, and more.
$6.69 +
Tropical Chicken
A refreshing choice with a tropical twist, combining pineapple, cranberries, with a light raspberry vinaigrette.
$6.69 +
Garden Supreme
Our signature Garden Salad got a new look!
$7.29 +
Custom Creation
Pick from the freshest veggies, tasty proteins, 6 cheeses, you are sure to make the perfect custom salad.
$4.09 +
Small Side Salad
Choice of base: Iceberg, Romaine, Spinach, or no base. Dressing options include Ranch, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, Thousand Island, Caesar, Italian, French, Catalina, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Fat Free Ranch, or no dressing.
$6.95 +
Extra Dressings
Choose your base: Iceberg, Romaine, Spinach, or no base. Dressing options include Ranch, Blue Cheese, Caesar, Italian, and more. Extra dressings available.
$0.12 +
16" Extra Large Pizza
16" Build Your Own Pizza
Make it your own! Build a pizza with any toppings just the way you want it.
$16.21 +
16" Texan
16" Texas-style pizza with customizable options including five types of crust and nine unique sauces such as marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and garlic herb.
$26.68 +
16" Plenty
16" Extra Large Pizza with various crust options (Regular, Thin, Thick, Pan, Cheezy Crust) and a choice of multiple sauces, including classics and unique drizzles.
$26.68 +
16" Premier
Your choice of crust and sauce, including options like Cheezy Crust or BBQ sauce. Customize to suit your taste.
$27.92 +
16" Tropics
Layers of tropical flavors on an extra large 16" pizza. Option of regular, thin, thick, pan, or cheezy crust. Choose from various sauces like marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and more.
$24.14 +
16" Garden
16" garden pizza. Choose from regular, thin, thick, pan, or cheezy crust. Sauces include no sauce, red (marinara), Alfredo, garlic herb, BBQ, ranch, buffalo, taco, mustard drizzle, buffalo drizzle, habanero mango.
$26.68 +
16" Texas Heat
16" Texas Heat
Choice of crust and a variety of sauces, including BBQ, Alfredo, and spicy options like Buffalo and Habanero Mango Drizzle.
$27.92 +
16" Chicken Alfredo
Chicken alfredo pizza topped with your choice of five crusts and ten unique sauces options like garlic herb or buffalo drizzle.
$26.68 +
16" Spinach Alfredo
Spinach Alfredo on a 16" pizza crust. Choose crust style; variety of sauces including Alfredo, Marinara, or BBQ.
$26.68 +
16" Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo chicken topped pizza on a 16" crust. Choice of Regular, Thin, Thick, Pan, or Cheezy Crust. Sauce options include marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and more.
$26.68 +
Breads
Breadsticks (12-14)
Seasoned breadsticks, baked to a golden brown and lightly brushed with garlic and herb butter.
$7.28 +
Cheezybread
Golden-brown bread topped with melted mozzarella and cheddar cheese, baked to a bubbly perfection.
$11.65 +
Bread Bites (15 pc)
Mini bread bites typically featuring garlic oil, parmesan cheese, and parsley.
$4.54 +
Bread Bites (30 pc)
Soft, garlicky bites of bread typically topped with butter and parmesan cheese.
$7.28 +
Cinna-strips
Strips of bread coated with cinnamon and sugar, drizzled with icing.
$8.47 +
Wings
Bone-In Wings (5 Pc)
Five bone-in wings. Choice of sauce: Plain, Hot, Honey BBQ, Habanero-Mango, Garlic Parmesan, or Lemon Pepper.
$8.99 +
Bone-In Wings (8 pc)
Eight bone-in wings with your choice of sauce: Plain, Buffalo Hot, Honey BBQ, Habanero-mango, Garlic Parmesan, or Lemon Pepper.
$14.77 +
Bone-In Wings (12 pc)
12 bone-in wings with a choice of sauces: Buffalo Hot, Honey BBQ, Habanero-mango, Garlic Parmesan, Lemon Pepper, or Plain.
$21.95 +
Boneless Chicken (8 pc)
Eight pieces of boneless chicken with choice of wing sauce: Plain, Buffalo Hot, Honey BBQ, Habanero-Mango, Garlic Parmesan, or Lemon Pepper.
$10.52 +
Boneless Chicken (12 pc)
12 pieces of boneless chicken wings. Choose from six sauces: Plain, Buffalo Hot, Honey BBQ, Habanero-Mango, Garlic Parmesan, Lemon Pepper.
$15.2 +
Pasta
Spaghetti Bowl
Spaghetti in a bowl, available in small or regular.
$8.41 +
Chicken Alfredo Bowl
Creamy Alfredo sauce, tender chicken, pasta. Choice of sizes: Small, Regular.
$10.49 +
Build Your Own Pasta Bowl
Choice of small or regular size. Options for spaghetti or penne pasta. Three sauce choices: regular marinara, chunky marinara, or Alfredo.
$7.37 +
Hot Sandwiches
Philly Steak Sandwich
Philly Steak, Provolone, Mozzarella, Green Pepper, Mushroom, and Onion.
$11.27 +
Italian Marinara
Salami, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Mozzarella, and Marinara (side)
$11.27 +
4 Cheese Melt
American, Mozzarella, Provolone, and Cheddar
$8.39 +
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich
Chicken, Bacon, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Pickles and Ranch (side).
Recommended- add buffalo sauce for that extra kick!
$11.87 +
Ham and Turkey Club
Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayonnaise
$11.27 +
Lone Star Melt
Roast Beef, Pastrami, Onion, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, and Mayonnaise
$13.07 +
Build Your Own Sandwich
Build your own custom sandwich here!
$7.19 +
Hot Sandwiches Combo
Kids 4 Cheese Melt Combo
4 Cheese Melt, Chips and Kids Drink
$10.79 +
Medium Philly Steak Sandwich Combo
Philly Steak Sandwich, Chips and Medium Drink Combo
$15.83 +
Medium Italian Marinara Combo
Italian Marinara, Chips, and Medium Drink Combo
$15.83 +
Medium 4 Cheese Melt Combo
4 Cheese Melt, Chips and Medium Drink
$12.59 +
Medium Chicken Bacon Ranch Combo
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich, Chips and Medium Drink
$15.83 +
Medium Ham and Turkey Club Combo
Club Sandwich, Chips and Medium Drink
$15.83 +
Medium Lone Star Melt Combo
Lone Star Melt, Chips and Medium Drink
$17.63 +
Medium Build Your Own Sandwich Combo
Build your own sandwich, chips and medium drink
$9.59 +
Large Philly Steak Sandwich Combo
Philly Steak Sandwich, Chips and Large Drink Combo
$17.39 +
Large Italian Marinara Combo
Italian Marinara, Chips, and Large Drink Combo
$17.39 +
Calzone
Calzone
Calzone
$11.22 +
Desserts
Cinna Strips
Soft, doughy strips topped with a generous layer of cinnamon and drizzled with sweet icing.
$8.47 +
**New** Cookie Cake 8in
8" Cookie Pizza cut into 8 slices.
$10.91 +
Dessert Pizzas
Fruit dessert pizzas with a choice of cherry, apple, or blueberry toppings.
$15.08 +
1 Brownie Cup
Brownie cup with choice of Chocolate Ganache or Caramel.
$4.91 +
2 Brownie Cups
Rich and decadent brownie cups available in Chocolate Ganache or Caramel flavors.
$9.11 +
Chips
Fritos
Crunchy corn chips with a savory, salty flavor.
$2.99 +
Mrs. Vickie's Sea Salt
Kettle-cooked potato chips seasoned with sea salt.
$2.99 +
Mrs. Vickie's Jalapeno
Kettle-cooked potato chips with a spicy jalapeño flavor.
$2.99 +
Sides
Cup Ranch
Make it your own! Build your own pizza with any toppings, just the way you want it.
$1.86 +
12oz Cup Ranch
A 12oz cup of our house-made ranch dressing, typically featuring buttermilk, garlic, and a mix of herbs and spices.
$5.35 +
32oz Cup Ranch
A 32-ounce container of our house-made ranch dressing, typically featuring buttermilk, sour cream, mayonnaise, garlic, and a mix of herbs and spices.
$14.09 +
Cup of Marinara
House-made marinara sauce featuring a blend of tomatoes, garlic, and herbs.
$1.25 +
Cup of Alfredo
Creamy alfredo sauce made with parmesan and a hint of garlic.
$1.25 +
Cup of Garlic Butter
Garlic butter typically includes fresh roasted garlic, mixed with butter and herbs, creating a creamy and aromatic dipping sauce.
$1.25 +
Cup Icing
A small cup of icing typically used for dipping or spreading on desserts.
$1.25 +
Cup of BBQ
Barbecue sauce typically includes smoked tomatoes, mustard, and brown sugar.
$1.25 +
Cup of Buffalo
Buffalo sauce typically made with cayenne, garlic, and butter, served in a cup.
$1.25 +
Cup of Habanero Mango
Habanero mango typically includes sweet mango chunks and spicy habanero peppers.
$1.25 +
Drinks
Gallon Sweet
Brewed fresh daily, this sweet tea offers a refreshing, sweetened flavor with a hint of lemon.
$6.85 +
Gallon Un-sweet
Brewed fresh daily, this gallon of unsweetened tea offers a refreshing, natural taste, served with a lemon wedge for a hint of citrus.
$6.85 +
Fountain Soda
20 oz or 32 oz. Variety of flavors such as Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, and Mountain Dew, alongside brewed teas.
$2.99 +
20oz Bottle Soda
Various 20oz bottle sodas including Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, A&W Root Beer, Mountain Dew, and Starry.
$3.11 +
2L Bottle Soda
2-liter bottle of soda. Choice of flavors including various colas, root beer, and citrus options.
$4.36 +
Bottled Water
Pure, refreshing bottled water.
$1.98 +