I've heard great things about this place and thought I'd try it. This place did not disappoint. Since moving here we've been craving a Sicilian pizza but haven't been able to find a place that offered it. This Sicilian Cheese Pizza 16" with pepperoni and sausage was wonderful!! Lots of toppings and very filling! The Ham Calzone was good as well. The pizza sauce was homemade with chunks of tomatoes and herbs and I think I hint of sweetness. We have lots of left overs to enjoy the rest of the week!
J
Jaxson C
8 contribuciones
Loved
• 9/1/25
• DoorDash order
The Cheese Pizza Slice and Pepperoni Pizza Slice were huge! I got 2 of each since I had never ordered from here be and it was so worth it. Not too much sauce, thin crust but not over cooked. I loved it, definitely ordering again
C
Charles L
4 contribuciones
Loved
• 8/8/25
• DoorDash order
1 Cheese Pizza 16” Sausage , Onions, Green Peppers & 12 Buffalo Wingz... I'm originally from New Jersey and this pizza tasted just like it was made in the Pizzaria(s) in Jersey & New York!! Wingz were great too, Just enough sauce and juicy as well. My new favorite Pizza Joint!!
A
A S
Nuevo experto • 48 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 12/7/25
• DoorDash order
⭐☆☆☆☆
Tried Brooklyn Pizza for the first time tonight and—safe to say—my taste buds have filed a restraining order. I wasn’t feeling well, so we ordered the chicken penne with vodka sauce, hoping for something comforting and flavorful. Instead, I got a mountain of flavorless penne swimming in disappointment. It’s like they cooked the noodles, whispered “vodka sauce” over them, and called it a day.
And the salad? If you can even call a handful of lettuce a “salad.” I’ve seen bigger garnishes on a burger. They didn’t even bother with dressing—unless you count the $1 I paid for “extra ranch,” which apparently means they send you a thimble of sadness.
Do yourself a favor: if you’re craving good Italian, try literally anywhere else. Brooklyn Pizza? More like Broken Promises Pizza.
C
Christine B
2 contribuciones
Loved
• 27/7/24
• DoorDash order
The pizza has a thin, tough, chewy dough - reminiscent of Philly/Jersey shore- type shops. Slightly burned crust edges add flavor and a not-unpleasant crunch ... these qualities are not a turn-off if you are used to pizza from this region. The red sauce is made thinner by the oregano-flavored oil shed by the mat of real cheese on top. Moderate "cheese pull" on an 18" with extra cheese. Better than anywhere else in York County,SC.
Cheese fries were enough to feed two. Crispy fries covered with mozzarella.
Tiramisu tasted like it came from a commercial baker - good enough to finish, not good enough to reorder.
