Do you love pizza, but hate the feeling of having to choose between eating good food or eating pizza? Are you craving pizza, but also thinking, "I should probably eat something better"? We think GOOD…
Both pizzas were excellent but the Margherita pizza was my favorite as always anywhere I have it. I ate both myself in one sitting so a single large Margherita will be my next order.
V
Victoria S
3 contribuciones
Loved
• 11/4/26
• DoorDash order
The best pizza in Oklahoma City! Best Cesar salad too! The dough is home made and so is everything else. I also had the sandwich and it was out standing. Portion size for the small pizza is perfect for yourself. My first time trying was about two weeks ago and I've been ordering ever since!
S
Suzanne F
Nuevo experto • 11 contribuciones
Loved
• 4/2/26
• DoorDash order
I'm kind of super picky about my Marg pizzas, and this one takes the cake!!!! Absolutely amazingMargherita pizza!! I have been searching for a good place to get a Margherita pizza when I come to visit for work and I have found it!! I mean, you'll have the issue of it not being super hot, but it's woodfire... Even if you drove it home, it wouldn't be hot. It's only going to be super hot if you eat it there. But it legit was amazing even at room temp! I will say that I did get extra cheese on mine and removed the basil. So that's why it has those changes in the picture.
W
Wendy S
3 contribuciones
Loved
• 2 days ago
• DoorDash order
I am from out of town and I was so incredibly impressed with the American Gothic Pizza- it was worth every single bite. Oh absolutely amazing you must try.
H
Heather R
6 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 24/6/26
• DoorDash order
This was my first time ordering from AGP, but unfortunately my experience was mixed. While the Caesar salad, rice crispy treat was really good, the pizza was really gross. The bottom was soggy, while the rim was burnt. The flavor of the sauce tasted burnt as well. I'm not sure if this was a fluke issue, but it was unfortunate and will make me hesitate to order from this establishment again.
