I grew up in Eastern Ohio in the 1980s and 90s and DiCarlo's pizza was a staple. I was staying in Hilliard, OH the other day and noticed there was a DiCarlo's nearby so I had to have it. I ordered a box (6 pieces) and it was everything I remembered. The super crispy crust, the tangy sauce and the cold cheese and pepperoni. Absolutely delightful. When it comes to Ohio Valley style pizza, if you know you know.
C
Chris G
2 contribuciones
Loved
• 30/11/24
• DoorDash review
One of my favorite pizzas. It is different and you should know the toppings including cheeses are put on after baking the crust and sauce- toppings are not cooked. The crust is like nothing else around, the sauce is pretty great too. I wish there were more topping choices. Somewhat expensive but worth trying.
G
Gavin B
8 contribuciones
Loved
• 9/4/23
• DoorDash order
HOLY COW!! This is the best pizza I have had here in Columbus. Very well done Ohio valley style pizza. Reminds me of wallys pizza in Cambridge and new concord. So delicious, if you like hot crispy pizza then this is absolutely for you!!!
M
Melissa K
15 contribuciones
Liked
• 25/6/25
• DoorDash order
Still good, but somewhat less so when there is raw dough under that sauce. The bottom looked done, there was even a little bit of crunch, but not like DiCarlo's is known for!Cook a little slower, let the crust get done.
M
Mark S
2 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 11/2/23
• DoorDash order
Literally nothing special about this restaurant whatsoever. The pizza doesn't have any unique flavor. In fact, it doesn't have much flavor at all. The sauce is watery and is not very flavorful either.
I have no idea how this place obtained it's current star rating. Mediocre pizza at best
