I'm genuinely impressed with this place. Ithaca only has a few great pizza places left, and Fat Tomato Pizza Co. is one of them. The pizza is giant, the toppings are fresh and plentiful (they don't skimp even a little), the wings are huge and not the least bit dry, I'm not sure what kind of blue cheese they use, but it's great too. I'll definitely be getting another pie again in the future.
K
Kim Joy E
2 contribuciones
Loved
• 1/4/26
• DoorDash order
Having lived in Italy, I like my pizza thin and crispy. I asked for my pizza to be cooked a bit longer to give me that thin & crispy taste I love. They delivered.
Regarding extra toppings, they were VERY generous !!! The sauce was very good, however a few Italian herbs, spices added would have made my pizza perfect. Experiment outside the box to knock it out of the park.
Pizza arrived on time (w/doordash) warm & fresh !
Cheers
